Link to forum discussions for manga


  • Premium Member

    Please add a link like you have at the end of the light novel chapters to discuss the latest manga chapter instead of having only a single mega-thread for the manga. I think this would be a simple thing to implement and would be useful for the community.


  • Premium Member

    Which single mega-thread are you talking about? I've only seen a topic for each volume so far and it seems reasonable to me. Even LNs have a single topic for each volume, and those have much more content to discuss compared to a manga.



  • Long ago when the site was first founded there was a single forum thread for every LN part.

    It was a mess, the day that Sam decided to do Volume threads instead of part threads was a good day, more then likely we won’t be going back.


  • Premium Member

    @rahul-balaggan said in Link to forum discussions for manga:

    Long ago when the site was first founded there was a single forum thread for every LN part.

    It was a mess, the day that Sam decided to do Volume threads instead of part threads was a good day, more then likely we won’t be going back.

    I remember those early days and wholeheartedly support Sam's move to whole volume threads.

    I assume the original concept was to replicate the fan translation experience where each chapter had its own comments section, but that only really works when the comments section is directly below the translated chapter.


  • Premium Member

    @terabyte Ah, the megathread thing has been fixed apparently. I think magic in this world is too far behind had one for a while.

    There is a link to the forums in the upper-right corner when you reach the end, my suggestion is just to point that link to the forum discussion for that volume of the manga.


  • Premium Member

    @pjthomas404 Oh, that one is a special case, just like Rokujouma. Both LNs are actually a "remaster" of the fan translations, so everything was kept in the same topic for those. I actually asked for a topic for each volume a while back too, but we're already caught up with both at this point, so no big deal. 😅