JNC Writing Support Group
-
@mononyan It will always depend on how much time you dedicated to writing. I have been cooking my book in my head for years, I wanted to put on paper but always neglected. In the end with the competition it took me around four months to write it (70k+ words). Right now I am stuck on the second volume, almost two months and 28k words, and I am dedicating time to learn more about blacksmithing to better represent it in the book.
From most light novels I have seen it, it will be around four months to a year between releases, which includes editing and revising, but it also good to notice that some of them were already webnovels before being published.
I would say take your time and enjoy it, otherwise if you push too hard it will become a hassle. -
@mononyan I started when I found out about the contest, and hit just less than 50k words.
I went in knowing that it would be difficult and decided that I didn’t have the luxury of planning, so I picked a genre I liked and and sort of used a story that I read years ago and hated as inspiration for my starting point. Then I decided I would essentially “fix” the story—making the characters likable and giving them depth. I also gave it unique “hook” that coincidentally helped hide some of the deficiencies in my writing skill. The characters ended up driving the story’s plot completely and I was lucky that the pieces fell into place and I stumbled onto an ending that I liked. It ended up nothing like the story that I hated. I did have one person proofread (once), which was helpful since I am very error-prone. I was happy with the result, but have avoided rereading it since the submission, because I am afraid of the errors I will inevitably find.The only other full length-novel I ever wrote was a fanfic and it probably took a year to write and it took another year to remove a lot of the errors and polish (I posted it with a ton of errors, some are still there). There were world building things I had to do for the contest story that I didn’t have to do for the fanfic—and the fanfic had a lot more humor—so some chapters were built around gags, which is easier for me to do well than drama.
-
@GhostMechanic It seems the competition was the perfect motivation you needed to start writing. Something similar happened with me. I entered a different competition in 2021 with the simple goals of wanting to try and also get reader opinions, which is when I converted the script into a book. It was riddled with errors and I didn't win, but still finished in time and felt satisfied.
@jazzyjeoff That's an interesting way to come up with a 'quick' idea! Also, I find a new error every time I read through my story so I can't blame you for avoiding rereading. I should have done the same with my submission.
×
Recently, when I REALLY get in the writing mood, I get called into work. A few weeks ago I almost completed an entire chapter within a few hours before I got the call. It's frustrating, but at least I sometimes have enough downtime at work to write notes, dialogue, etc.
-
@mononyan I started 21st December and managed to finish 99k words by 31st January. But I burnt myself out in the process, so would not recommend.
Everyone writes differently, but I would be happy with 500-1000 words per day.
-
Hi there. For the answer it depends on the deadline :) I have a horrible habit of playing around with stories when they don’t have a reason to be written quickly.
No - there is a long, long “mulling” time and often a short writing period followed by a significant editing phase.
My best is 80,000 words in a week (because I had to take time off work to finish) but there were at least three more edits after the rough words were down on a page. On a good day I can do between 3-5,000 words. But it is all the days in between that catch me.
-
@Damon-Cavalchini
80,000 words in a week? That’s just insane! -
@mononyan said in JNC Writing Support Group:
I have a different story that would suit this kind of contest better, but even if I start now I'm confident it won't be done by the deadline. I'll get to it after the other one.
Start and see how you go. I have an isekai that I have been playing around with in my head that I should be working on for the next round instead of writing a sequel for one of the novels I submitted to this competition on the dream it gets picked up and they need another quickly :)
The only advice I can give is to write at your pace rather than worrying about a deadline that hasn’t been announced.
Once we know what is happening, so will you. Until then, just enjoy the act of writing and creating.
-
@jazzyjeoff said in JNC Writing Support Group:
@Damon-Cavalchini
80,000 words in a week? That’s just insane!I will never do it again. It was one of those opportunities I found out about really late and was caught in very time-intensive job so I had to grab the chance to write when I could.
-
@jazzyjeoff said in JNC Writing Support Group:
How are y’all doing. Just finished watching the most recent episode of Apothecary Diaries (wonderful!), which leaves me counting down to the next episode of Frieren—I am going to feel a little lost when their seasons’ end (open to replacement suggestions!).
Watching them has me convinced that most great stories have their fair share of plotholes—but if the reader (viewer) becomes sufficiently invested, a lot can be overlooked—even for a story that is pretty smart.I think there is a general misunderstanding about plot holes in general (not saying in this case). A plot hole should really be where the plot contradicts itself - not where something is unexplained.
Apothecary Dairies often leaves things under explained (relying on the reader/viewer to join the dots) but in my opinion doesn’t actually contradict itself.
I haven’t seen the last episode so maybe it does but I haven’t really seen too many glaring errors to date.
That said, I will forgive a lot for great characters and an intriguing story.
-
@GhostMechanic said in JNC Writing Support Group:
...I am dedicating time to learn more about blacksmithing to better represent it in the book.
That's something I never really considered before writing my story - skills/crafts/etc. that I had no knowledge of. Some things I was happy to handwave, like how they run a cryptocurrency on steam-powered Babbage-era calculating engines (look, it's fantasy, OK?), but other things I wanted to present realistically like horses and riding so I had to read up about that.
For my second volume, which is currently at 7K words, I had to learn about boats and sailing.
-
@mononyan said in JNC Writing Support Group:
Hello fellow writers! I was curious about something and figured I'd ask here: on average how long does it take you to finish writing a novel? I was amazed when reading the competition thread that some people started when the contest was announced and managed to write 80-100k words!
Because of time management and not finding out about the contest until fairly late, I wrote mine in about a month. I got about 1.5k by end of December, and did another 38k or so in January before I submitted on the 30th.
I think my best word count on any given day was about 2.5k; but I find that I am constantly revising and editing sentences as I write, so without those deletions my actual daily word count is probably at least 1k higher.
I work the afternoon shift from 3-11pm, and I usually have to leave the house by 1:30pm to get there on time because the traffic can be bad, then I get home just before midnight. So in January I would wake up between 9:30-10am, write for a couple hours, go to work, come back, and then write some more from midnight to 1 or 2am before bed. Most of those days I would only get a couple hundred words done, it was Saturdays and Sundays where I had to just pound it out.
As for my best time... back in high school I was in a writing class and decided to write a novel for my final project. Being lazy and procrastinating, I did almost nothing until the due date was almost there. Then I had to pound out 3/4 of the novel in just two days and hope that there was enough paper and printer ink in the house. It would have been one day, but I was helped out by a massive snowfall that cancelled the school buses and gave me one extra day to write. I never want to do that again...
-
My Tearmoon fan-fiction just broke 10,000 views on Royal Road. That translates to maybe 200 people that read the whole thing, but it makes me very happy—especially since it seems that most folks that started reading it finished reading it. My goal when writing it was to have three people read it and maybe enjoy it.
Anyway, for me it is happy thing and I wanted to share. -
@jazzyjeoff said in JNC Writing Support Group:
My Tearmoon fan-fiction just broke 10,000 views on Royal Road. That translates to maybe 200 people that read the whole thing, but it makes me very happy—especially since it seems that most folks that started reading it finished reading it. My goal when writing it was to have three people read it and maybe enjoy it.
Anyway, for me it is happy thing and I wanted to share.Woo hoo. Congratulations. Writing something that people read and engage with is an amazing thing.
And based on what I’ve read so far, you’re a show-in for the next round. :)
-
@jazzyjeoff said in JNC Writing Support Group:
My Tearmoon fan-fiction just broke 10,000 views on Royal Road. That translates to maybe 200 people that read the whole thing, but it makes me very happy—especially since it seems that most folks that started reading it finished reading it. My goal when writing it was to have three people read it and maybe enjoy it.
Anyway, for me it is happy thing and I wanted to share.And another finished reader and happy customer. Great stuff. It is really easy to see this as another alternative timeline to what we eventually got in the official books.
-
@Damon-Cavalchini Thanks so much for the kind words!
-
I know it's rather late, but thanks a lot for the kind well-wishes, :) I really appreciate them.
The first round results are just around the corner now. For those who aren't able to progress to the second round, I was thinking we could organize something to give feedback to those who request it. Anyone else out there interested in volunteering for this? I intend to help, but I tend to disappear suddenly whenever I get a FM and/or ME flareup, or wind up in the hospital.
-
@Alfaerin
I would volunteer and most probably put my work in this channel, too -
Hi there,
Glad to see you around Alfaerin and look after yourself. This is kind of what we want to do with proposed review and feedback thread.
Just a note of caution - we need to ensure that we can share our stories if/when they don’t continue in the competition. Normally, you have to wait until the competition is finished for several reasons (including avoiding debates around did and did not progress).
I definitely think we can support each other here and recognise that there are many reasons why works may not progress which aren’t just about the quality of writing.
They are cutting from around 500 to around 100 so 4/5 stories won’t go through the first gate which can’t all be based solely on poor writing (and I’m pretty sure most of the people on here won’t be knocked for their writing quality alone).
We should also probably wait for a public announcement of who is progressing before sharing - even if we have personally received an email. We don’t know how they will be getting in touch with everyone or whether timing may be affected by the public holidays.
Good luck everyone. Only a couple of weeks to go.
As I’ve said several times on here, I want to progress but even if I don’t, the competition itself was worthwhile and I have already started on submissions for the next one.
-
Thanks again ^^ I already asked about privately sharing our works for feedback purposes, and was told that was okay. They just don't want us making our work public while it's being judged.
https://forums.j-novel.club/post/337344
@Alfaerin Yeah, sharing the title and summary is fine, and privately sharing to other people or getting advice from others is also perfectly okay.
We've been kicking around some ideas, but haven't really set anything concrete in motion just yet. So I was thinking we ought to iron out something in time for the results of the first round of judging., and probably make a new topic specifically about offering feedback to those who didn't make it past the first round. I'd like to say I can live with it if I don't progress, but well... I really entered hoping to win, because I need money to pay for medicine and treatments I need.
-
@Alfaerin said in JNC Writing Support Group:
Thanks again ^^ I already asked about privately sharing our works for feedback purposes, and was told that was okay. They just don't want us making our work public while it's being judged.
https://forums.j-novel.club/post/337344
@Alfaerin Yeah, sharing the title and summary is fine, and privately sharing to other people or getting advice from others is also perfectly okay.
We've been kicking around some ideas, but haven't really set anything concrete in motion just yet. So I was thinking we ought to iron out something in time for the results of the first round of judging., and probably make a new topic specifically about offering feedback to those who didn't make it past the first round. I'd like to say I can live with it if I don't progress, but well... I really entered hoping to win, because I need money to pay for medicine and treatments I need.
Thanks for asking about what rules @Alfaerin.
Let’s use this as an opportunity to solidify the things we’ve been chatting about for a while. I’ll look to set up a thread on the weekend (this gives me the push to move things forward).
