Question: How JNC license novels?
-
@Paul-Nebeling @eins I agree with Eins, but your reasons sound kind of facetious so I'm not sure if you actually want him to want to read it lol.
AW's main advantage over SAO is innate character pathos. SAO's characters are kind of bland/generically "cool," which is the main detractor from the GGO arc, artificially giving Kirito "depth" by giving him all of a sudden this retroactive fear of... I don't even know, losing his humanity or something? Thereafter there's this whole "the best gamer in the world could be even better except he can't take games seriously anymore so cry for him" thing that makes me roll my eyes.
Anyway, AW's characters are completely based around personal flaws, which makes them inherently more interesting since as the audience you're naturally driven to want to know more about how their duel avatars formed, you want to look for clues about the characters written between the lines. I also love that the mythology feels so vast due to the nature of Brain Burst, there's so much history to dig into, and it has this modern legend feel; like even though everything is entirely in the future, you still feel like you're in a classic medieval Joseph Campbell hero's journey.
Accel World is my favorite ongoing (English published) light novel, I pretty much can't wait to read it whenever a new (English) book is released.
-
@myskaros said in Question: How JNC license novels?:
SAO's characters are kind of bland/generically "cool," which is the main detractor from the GGO arc, artificially giving Kirito "depth" by giving him all of a sudden this retroactive fear of... I don't even know, losing his humanity or something? Thereafter there's this whole "the best gamer in the world could be even better except he can't take games seriously anymore so cry for him" thing that makes me roll my eyes.
I would not say it was artificial as the Laughing Coffin subjugation was in the very first volume of the novels, and they go more in-depth regarding Kirito so I could better understand where he was coming from, unlike in the anime (SAOII was a horrid adaptation IMO).
Also, wouldn't that technically make him take the games more seriously, not less? Don't know what you mean with the whole "cry for him" part either... Only character I can attribute that to is Yuuki. -
This post is deleted! -
@doublemangekyo said in Question: How JNC license novels?:
I would not say it was artificial as the Laughing Coffin subjugation was in the very first volume of the novels
It's basically a retcon. Instead of it being a part of his character from the start, with hints dropped along the way so that the audience has some indication that it's going to be a problem later, the author picked an event that he didn't spend a lot of time describing and inserted something to retroactively give the character an attribute he didn't have before.
The part in quotes is basically me being facetious + melodrama. I mean, seriously, he's already a Gary Stu, but now we also have to grapple with "if only he would take things more seriously, then he'd be even more powerful!!!1." And I don't know how to respond to the other part, given that they clearly say that he'll "never" take VRMMOs seriously again, so he'll never be "as strong" as he could be.
Whoever said nothing's impossible never tried slamming a revolving door.
-
@myskaros I was aiming for something like a list of potential turn offs to reading it. If you can handle those then you can enjoy it. I actually like the series.
-
@eins said in Question: How JNC license novels?:
@myskaros I was aiming for something like a list of potential turn offs to reading it. If you can handle those then you can enjoy it. I actually like the series.
I see. That's... an interesting way to recommend a series, haha, can't say I've seen that approach before O.o
-
@myskaros @DoubleMangekyo SAO has problems with several of its arcs, but the most glaring ones are with the Aincrad arc. So many retcons and backfills. The original story that is given in Volume 1 starts on the 74th floor and ends a scant three weeks later, two of which are largely skipped over. Everything else that is considered canon about Aincrad was written later and shoehorned into the original story with varying success. Don't get me wrong. I like SAO, but it was the first light novel I ever read. Now that I have read many more, I can honestly say this.
Reki Kawahara is a good light novel author, and his writing skills have improved tremendously over the years, but he's not the best light novel author out there. I like his work, but there are other authors I like just as much or more.
-
@paul-nebeling Yep, I know. That's the problem with taking a complete "short story" and trying to serialize it without starting from scratch. In retrospect, SAO:Progressive is what Kawahara should have done in the first place instead of trying to continue the story using the original Aincrad book as a base.
Honestly, I really do like Kawahara's stuff, not as much for the characters or the story, but for the sci-fi. The real gold from all the SAO arcs is his imagination on ways VR/AR technology can affect people's lives. AW book 5 is probably my favorite because, in the middle of reading it, I took a 2 hour break to research orbital elevators, and it was fantastic.
-
@myskaros I'm glad I'm not the only one that looked up orbital elevators while reading vol. 5. That's my favorite Volume in the series.
-
I’m quite happy Aincrad didn’t go on forever, I liked GGO a lot and like the series being an ongoing look at different VR games in the future world. All that sci-if stuff would be missing from an ongoing virtual dungeon delve book. I like Progressive (it wasn’t actually the first SAO I read) but am also happy the narrative didn’t spend a dozen books there before moving on.
