High School DxD
-
@jon-mitchell said in High School DxD:
@timmaaah
I agree, (and I'd like to see this title licensed)
however - if the fan-translation is good and free - how well would official version sell?I think it depends a bit. If the fan-translations start pushing for readers to buy the official version to compare, at least some of the readers will. Otherwise, I'd say it really depends on the series. For example, if Kino no Tabi was made available properly, I'd definitely buy the English version. I bought both the JP and EN version of GGO due to liking the author's works.
Some fan-translations will push for the official (some will even voluntarily start taking down their translations as the official version comes out). Think of it sort of like pre-pub vs premium ebook in that sense.
I think the problem with DxD is whether or not the bonuses will push people to buy it since I know there is at least one publisher that isn't really friendly with bonuses. You'll definitely have a few buyers, but the question is more 'will there be enough'. Unlike how a fan-translation group can pick up a volume, see if there is enough interest, and drop it if there isn't, JNC can't realistically go: Ok, we'll license one volume, see how it does, and if it doesn't sell, we'll renegotiate the license so another company can pick it up from the start.
I mean, they could, but they aren't really set up for that kind of thing.
-
For everyone questioning how well it would sell because of the fan translation look at How Not to Summon a Demon Lord which has a much better fan translation available than DxD has that is practically caught up but as far as I know hasn't done much to interfere with sales.
-
Another potential issue with a DxD translation - the sub and dub of the show have very different tones (and translation conventions). If you’re trying to get fans to the show to buy the books, and not just LN fans,, pleasing both groups would be difficult.
-
@hamsterexastris said in High School DxD:
Another potential issue with a DxD translation - the sub and dub of the show have very different tones (and translation conventions). If you’re trying to get fans to the show to buy the books, and not just LN fans,, pleasing both groups would be difficult.
That's like literally the last issue to worry about, it's really not something that makes or breaks the deal for tv-show watchers.
-
@hamsterexastris I agree that what Funimation did with the dub is pretty much immaterial to anyone who would be inclined to read the books. The manga translation is closer to the subtitles than the dub, as well.
The dub was so irritating to me that I have two copies of each episode for viewing on my tablet - subtitled and dubbed, and which I watch depends my mood. Usually it's the sub, where Isei isn't quite the pig he is in the dub.
-
@novurdim said in High School DxD:
That's like literally the last issue to worry about, it's really not something that makes or breaks the deal for tv-show watchers.
It depends on the watcher. I found the fan translation a tough slog and gave up after volume 2. I’d give a real translation another shot, but 20 volumes of Issei calling Rias “President” and with a lower humor quotient would be painful.
-
I think most people who are used to multiple media sources are used to the LNs being different.
Just look at The Saga of Tanya the Evil or Yojo Senki. The anime is VERY different from the LNs. There are stuff that is elaborated on in the Anime that is barely even mentioned in the LN and vice versa.
-
@guspaz Of course I'm not saying everyone should donate 600$ but rather motivate more people to donate 20 - 30 with a little bait. once it does come out... if... then most of those vol. 1 owners will gradually spend their money on the sequels.
The initial 300k should come from many donating 20 - 30 not few spending 600.
Yes it is unrealistic. Very few people in the west even know that LNs exist and just think of most anime as cliffhanger stories and thats it. Many people who do know and like DxD have likely read fan translations already, and most just pirate anime and manga as well anyway. So finding DxD loving LN readers that aren't stingy despite currently having it available for free, donating to a "let's hope" campaign... uh yeah...
Still the concept isn't bad. I think...
-
@hamsterexastris said in High School DxD:
I found the fan translation a tough slog and gave up after volume 2. I’d give a real translation another shot, but 20 volumes of Issei calling Rias “President” and with a lower humor quotient would be painful.
Of course, but it's not a question of sub vs dub, this is the issue of translation quality in general.
-
@fischus As a publisher, you can't start a kickstarter to fund a license without having already signed the license, otherwise you're accepting money for something you don't have any rights to. You need to already be very certain in advance that the kickstarter will succeed for the full amount for all volumes. You can't use the kickstarter to speculatively gauge interest.
I suppose they could try to sign some sort of conditional license with the publisher, but we're talking about an industry where some companies still don't even allow ebooks to exist, and even if you could get a conditional license, it would make you look really bad if the kickstarter failed.
-
@fischus It’s irrational I agree. Desperate times call for desperate state measures though.
-
Hate the say it I think the ship has sailed on this LN, which is sad sense it was my first introduction LN
there are three main reason as to why we will never see a office English release.
Large number of volumes
as of now there are over 27 volumes of the LN. 25 for the first and 2 for the ongoing second part. The cost for the licenses on this would be very expensive. It would alos mean a well over 10 year commitment to publishing.
Anime
While a anime is usually a shot in the arm for a LN this would actually hurt it. There are 4 seasons with a 5th on the way adapting I believe the first 7 or so LN. This would hurt sales as many fans would not buy books on plot they mostly know. While most anime cover maybe the first 2 or 3 volumes its not so much to dissuade people from reading for the more detailed info. How not to summon a demon lord is a good example of this. It would be almost two years of steady novel release to come out before any technically new contest would come out.
Fan Translations
Currently the first 26 volumes of this LN have very well done fan translations with full PDF support. This means a large part of the most devout fans have already read the novels so there would no reason to buy the novels meaning sales might not be good
Like I said this saddens me as it was my first LN series I read and would actually love a full English release but as I saith I don't think its in the cards.
-
@ant13099 I have to disagree on two points. First the anime. After watching all the available seasons for the first time somewhat recently, I want to buy to the light novels to find out what happens. We have zero indication a season 5 is happening at all. I would like to see/read for myself how the story goes without relying on a wiki or sub par fan translations.
This brings me to my second point. Grammatically and phrasing wise they appear to be a train wreck. The person who translated it may have (I don’t know if they did or not) done a good job with a literal translation, but it ends up sounding very poor in English. Trying to read the first few pages of vol 1 for example are embarrassingly bad.
-
Yeah, we'll have to agree to disagree on how well done the translation is.
I'm quite thankful for any translation, but the translations need /so/ much editing - in every facet from grammar to puncutation to spelling.
-
You guys reasons don't make any sense they already licensing old series like Sorcerous Stabber Orphen and long one like Invaders of the Rokujouma and stil on going and many ecchi series ...
-
@croix I think it's less to do with the length of the series and more about the amount of money that the JP publisher is wanting for the series licence. JNC must have got Orphen for significantly less than DxD, otherwise licencing a series like Orphen doesn't make sense since it's a similar length, but has no real fan base in the English market.
-
@croix Rokujuma is an exception, they were able to employ the fan translator to polish his work since it was allready quite good translation.
It's probably not possible for DxD since the fantranslation isn't good enough, was made by multiple group and it's not sure the publisher would accept such contract.
But it's true that just length is not the issue, it's length plus a mostly complete fantranslation, plus a long anime and manga, plus a difficult publisher plus a fanbase which may not be really book oriented... -
@timmaaah But they get licencing Amagi Brilliant Park and now Full Metal Panic from the same publisher i don't think this the real problem
-
@croix just because it’s the same publisher that doesn’t mean it will be the same licensing fees for each series, there are a multitude of things that can Fluctuate the price up and down, DxD has multiple anime seasons vs Amagi with 1 season, DxD sells more in Japan, DxD is longer (significantly longer) so the cost would also be more.
And I agree with @Timmaaah it probably has a lot to do with money (as in they want a lot), but that probably isn’t the sole reason...
-
@rahul-balaggan I wish we had more insight on this. It would also be nice to know if there even is any interest in licensing the series. I know personally, I would pay more per novel, just to see it licensed.