Novel Numbering...
-
The headache is that the "series" title is in the same field as the "book" title. What you really want to do is to use the title alone in the title, then sort by series (if exists), then title. I get this all the time in mysteries where sometimes, the metadata includes the series title, and sometimes, it doesn't.
-
There is another thing you can do.
Make a suggestion to the creator of the app you are using to make a sorting algorithm that handles text based numbers differently. There are some that sort mostly alphabetical but when they find numbers they evaluate the value of all the adjacent numbers rather than the ASCII (or other typeset like EBCIDIC) value of the number. The latest windows operating systems have started doing things like that in File Explorer, and I like it very much.
-
@malloc said in Novel Numbering...:
There is another thing you can do.
Make a suggestion to the creator of the app you are using to make a sorting algorithm that handles text based numbers differently. There are some that sort mostly alphabetical but when they find numbers they evaluate the value of all the adjacent numbers rather than the ASCII (or other typeset like EBCIDIC) value of the number. The latest windows operating systems have started doing things like that in File Explorer, and I like it very much.
This made me think there might already be something for Calibre like this with all of its plugins and whatnot.
So looked through some settings and sure enough there is.Preferences > Tweaks > Find: Recognize numbers inside text when sorting
Edit tweak > Change 'False' to 'True'numeric_collation = True
It seems to work from the couple I tested but looks like there could be some issues if titles start with numbers though, I'll leave this setting as true for now - but I'll still be adding the leading zero to my volume numbers.
-
@khaos human sort is not a very hard thing to implement and not doing so for things like this is just laziness.
-
This post is deleted! -
@khaos I don't think he means what you responded to, but I could be wrong. There should be a programmatic solution to "human sort"/custom sort objects. Simply designate each volume a number, and have your reader clients sort by that number. I'm sure it already exists for the various English literature that envelops all books under a "series" umbrella but names each book differently (like Game of Thrones).
-
eh... I just bypass the whole numbering thing and I just order my books in date downloaded descending, so I've always got the most recent purchases at the top.
-
@myskaros
You mean by making a series and sorting by series number?I do add my volumes to a series and assign them the appropriate number, which is fine and all if you were to stay in that manager's environment, but personally I user Calibre and Play Books, and Play Books can only sort by Title/Author/Recent...
-
@khaos said in Novel Numbering...:
@myskaros
You mean by making a series and sorting by series number?Yes, because series such as Kokoro Connect, for example, do not have a strict series number in the title, so there would need to be another method for the layperson to indicate that "Oh, Hito Random comes before Kizu Random."
-
True - which is also the case for Mixed Bathing - I just addend the volume to the title though.
Mixed Bathing in Another Dimension: Volume 01: The Hero of the Unlimited Bath
But with Kokoro Connect - oddly when added to Calibre it already had a volume number in the title.
Kokoro Connect Volume 1: Hito Random
-
@khaos Sure, you can do it manually, but springboarding off Steelblaidd's comment, it's just lazy not to provide that information in the first place as the publisher.
-
@myskaros Sorry, programmer speak. 'Human sort' means an algorithm that sorts things the way a human would. I was trying to say that any media app that doesn't know how to do so is deficient as at most its 20 lines of additional code to implement.
-
@khaos said in Novel Numbering...:
This is mainly just curiosity, it's a little tedious to change the title's metadata for all my volumes, but I can get over it.
Referencing title metadata but not series numbering? That's your problem.
-
@taedirk
Hmm this was brought up earlier...So when I or others are using a different library manager that is unable to reference a series number, what is our problem?
-
@khaos said in Novel Numbering...:
@taedirk
Hmm this was brought up earlier...So when I or others are using a different library manager that is unable to reference a series number, what is our problem?
Using under-featured management programs. Let's say you want to read the Wheel of Time series and grab the first three books (The Eye of the World, The Great Hunt, The Dragon Reborn). Hope you remember the order they're in because they certainly don't have series numbers baked into the title.
-
@taedirk No, you can not propose everyone to conform to one manager that in itself is lacking in other areas especially coming to syncing between devices or even compatibility between different devices.
Either way this is getting off topic, moving on...
-
@steelblaidd As a programmer if someone asked me to give them a "human sort" I would ask them for more information. "Just sort it as a human would", is way too ambiguous since there are literally millions of ways a human would sort it and everyone's "human sort" could be different.
Also please note that the only thing that is changing is the comparator (comparison method, routine, function, procedure, operation, whatever you want to call it because different programming languages call it different things) and the main sorting algorithm could and would most likely stay the same (bubble sort, quick sort, merge sort, etc.) However most non programmers wouldn't realize this so this point really is not that important so long as the programmer understands what the person requesting the change really wants.
Sort by series and volume number would be ideal, but if the publisher did not include that info in the metadata of the file then sorting by alphabetical title until you see a number would be a backup. Also remember that the more complex you make the comparison function the more time the sort will take. It won't be noticeable sorting 100 books but sorting thousands of books it will definitely be noticeable.