-
Just saw the first episode and I have to say that I am very happy with what I've seen. The anime seems to do the LN and the Manga justice. The animation seems to be done very well and they are sticking to the story line pretty closesly. While some other anime this last season have left a sour taste in our mouths, ArifuretaHint Hint, I am getting the feeling that this one will not be one of those. But I have to say that the lead in might have a little spoiler in there. But with how far along JNC is on the translation I don't think we are too far off from where that will happen in the story.
-
Can't say I'm super fond of the art and animation but I still have hopes that it will otherwise manage things well.
Also, is it just me or does Myne look older than she does in the manga and LN illustrations?
-
I just finished watching the first episode. I'm happy. I didn't consider that opening scene to be any sort of spoiler, but it does frame everything as a flashback/recollection of sorts. That post-credit scene sort of nailed that impression, and I got quite the chuckle from the High Priest's "No spoilers, fool!"
-
I overall agree that the lead in is not much of a spoiler. I feel that they needed to show that this was a magic world in order to hook some of the viewers. The light novels do not mention or even imply anything about magic till the very end of book 1 part 1.
Edit: Added the "part 1" due to the odd way the books are named for this series
-
I will admit the beginning isn't much of a spoiler but I still would have preferred that not show it.
-
1st episode is quite good. the first 90s is something of the part 2 but its not something I will consider spoiler and quite justified because the story telling require a lot of narrative.
the artwork and animation do resemble 90ish anime tho. especially when Mayne do the "cartoons" narrative. -
It was interesting that Urano world was referred to as "era", sounds more like time traveling reincarnation rather than Isekai. That was not translation choice but the editorial choice the original Anime made. Seems to be watering down "isekai" concept for wider audience?
-
@shyevsa said in Ascendance of a Bookworm - anime discussion:
the artwork and animation do resemble 90ish anime tho. especially when Mayne do the "cartoons" narrative.
That also looks a lot like Lizzie McGuire to me, lol. That's something where it literally goes into cartoon mode for some inner thoughts, but is otherwise live-action.
Also, I would have preferred them not show that first bit, having no LN experience but still adaptation experience in the manga, but makes sense.
And even though the art & animation isn't amazing, this was definitely the LN adaptation I've seen this year where the pilot impressed me the most. In fact finding it hard to say wether I liked it more than Dr. Stone/Astra, but those are ones I knew the source of, so it's hard to compare.
-
I feel like there was some scenes that got a lot of atention from the stuff. Like in the market when all the people moving, and myne "headache" (lol).
But other wise, its very still and showing a lot of background while character speaks to save money. Its good over all though. Could have been wores (arifureta). Some of the jokes where funnier in the manga.But the thing that bothers me the most is the colour palette. Too much brown! I mean, really? I get it that they try to give the impression that world witout books is monochrome, but they took it too far.
-
I was amused that they used footnote in the Anime. Although, it is strange that this particular one seems to be in the original too.
-
@hiroto I think its because the way the narrative is from Mayne and High Priest point of view. so it more like Mayne telling a story to High Priest, There is also because the current world resemble the Past Era of Urano's original world timeline, which can translate into "given enough time" their two world will be no different from one and another (in books availability context).
-
-
-
If they do her eyes when she's angry well, they'll make good gifs
-
I wonder if that footnote is indicative of how it's going to explain certain concepts or works later on. like, for example, the different trials she does
-
I've kinda been reading that a lot of people have an issue with the drawing of the characters for this series. While everyone is entitled to their own opinion I don't find this to be an issue. It would seem that the anime style is more reflective with the actual illustrations in the light novels and not so much the manga. While I will admit that the artwork in the manga is extremely good, I feel that going with a style that is closer to the light novel gives this anime a more rustic feel, and in a good way. The quality is not bad, it's actually quite good in my opinion and since this is a middle ages type of setting i'm liking how they went with an art style that is closer to the light novel vs the manga. But again, this is just my opinion.
-
To be honest I didn't find the first episode all that interesting, I'm hoping it picks up for me once Myne actually starts doing things.
-
@eternal-wanderer It will. Don't worry.
-
@eternal-wanderer that was me when I first started reading the novel but it should be the same with the anime in some way
I should start watching this once there's at least 3-5 episodes up
-
It's better than what the PV showed, but I feel like the anime format doesn't really add anything to the story, and actually doesn't fit it well.
I think I'm just going to wait for the GIF of Myne going "Bhuw" rather than seeing the whole thing.
