-
@AliceCheshire different studio entirely, so if the ball is dropped it'll be in entirely different ways.
-
@Libri-Liberorum said in Ascendance of a Bookworm - anime discussion:
Before season 3 was announced, I was told that it would be unusual to have more than two seasons, but it got more. Also in my fairly limited experience, if a season n+1 happens, it gets announced near or after the end of season n. (For example, we've just recently had an announcement of season 3 of Apothecary Diaries just as season 2 finishes.)
I think I've been miscounting seasons. I was thinking season 1 = part one (daughter of a soldier), season 2 = part 2 (shrine maiden), season 3 = first part of adopted daughter, and then a season 4 had been announced before season 3 had aired, which I thought weird.
However, actually season 1 = daughter of soldier, seasons 2 and 3 = shrine maiden, season 4 has been announced some time ago and the news is just that now it has a firm(ish) release date.
So this was a misunderstanding on my part.
-
@Libri-Liberorum said in Ascendance of a Bookworm - anime discussion:
@Libri-Liberorum said in Ascendance of a Bookworm - anime discussion:
Before season 3 was announced, I was told that it would be unusual to have more than two seasons, but it got more. Also in my fairly limited experience, if a season n+1 happens, it gets announced near or after the end of season n. (For example, we've just recently had an announcement of season 3 of Apothecary Diaries just as season 2 finishes.)
I think I've been miscounting seasons. I was thinking season 1 = part one (daughter of a soldier), season 2 = part 2 (shrine maiden), season 3 = first part of adopted daughter, and then a season 4 had been announced before season 3 had aired, which I thought weird.
However, actually season 1 = daughter of soldier, seasons 2 and 3 = shrine maiden, season 4 has been announced some time ago and the news is just that now it has a firm(ish) release date.
So this was a misunderstanding on my part.
It isn't too unusual, originally the first season was supposed to be a 24-ish episode run that covered all of part 1 and part 2 up until just after the trombe hunt, but COVID interrupted the schedule with a long break in the middle and then it was listed on streaming services as season 1 part 1 and season 1 part 2, but then by the time they got to the US Blu Ray release it was sold in a single box as seasons 1 and 2.
-
@GeorgeMTO said in Ascendance of a Bookworm - anime discussion:
@AliceCheshire different studio entirely, so if the ball is dropped it'll be in entirely different ways.
Well let's hope the new studio doesn't continue down the same path as the previous one then. I'm really not sure what they were thinking with season 3. They constantly had music playing during dark and serious scenes that was way too cheerful for the actual atmosphere of the scenes. They also kept sweeping the darker parts of the story under the rug which would really bite them when it comes to the Hasse execution. I think I complained about this point earlier in the thread but they were writing themselves into a corner where they either whitewash one of the darkest parts of the story and completely undermine the impact or they show the execution as it was written and get criticized by people who don't read the manga or novels for it being extremely jarring compared to the rest of the series.
-
@AliceCheshire, that's kind of the problem with Bookworm, though, isn't it. At first glance, it seems like a cute all-age story about the adventures of a little girl, but underneath that thin veneer there are some very dark things going on.
Have Studio Wit ended up with the proverbial poisoned chalice? We'll just have to wait and see how they cope, but a studio of that caliber ought to be able to make it work somehow.
-
@stardf29 You say it looks low-budget, but the budget is definitely higher than during the previous seasons
-
@NAme Just pointing out that you're replying to a post from 2019... They were talking previous seasons.
-
The Twitter account for the anime just released new key art for S4, adapting Part 3, for two consecutive cours! The updated trailer shows quite improved animation and teases the new opening, "Pages" from Little Glee Monster. Excited since we'll have up to 26 episodes so I expect less cuts than we got for Part 2 of the series. Can't wait for this to air in April for half a year!
-
@Xyarn part 2 had 20 episodes to adapt 4 volumes, so essentially 5 episodes per volume. If they do all of part 3 in those 2 cours, that's 26 episodes to adapt 5 volumes, 5.2 episodes per volume. That doesn't give it much more room to prevent cuts to me.
-
@GeorgeMTO I stand corrected. Possibly would see less of the side stories of P3 adapted then. I forgot about that OVA episode introducing Justus and Eckhart from a side story from P3V2 for half that episode. Quite a lot present in P3, though I would like to hope it is handled better this time.
I pray that the side stories following around the end of P3 get better adaptations or screen time than the few seconds of Myne's mourning from the last episode of last season, P2V4 epilogue with the black cloth and the neighbors of her family.
-
Well... In a "blink and you will miss it" (as unlike Hartmut who was pointed out directly, they where not) during that Baptism scene, we had:
Brunhilde, Ottilie, Leberecht, someone who may or may not be Leonore (but I suspect she is), Rihyarda, Oswald (I could have done without his presence really) and Geibe Haldenzel. I did not see Angelica or Lieseleta, nor did I see Bonifatius (poor him) but I may have missed them. I think I also saw the current Geibe Leisegang.
As for the rest, they did resequence some of the more important dialog, probably to make it flow better with the animation. A pity they cut short Myne's response to Brigitte's introduction (and Damuel's reintroduction) because Spoiled Brat #1 was too eager to lead our protagonist to her fated Clifthanger.
Nice touch in the OP to allude to some of the LN's or manga covers and nice touch in the ending to show scenes of Part 1 and 2.
Next week: Re-introduction to the temple's people as well as the next appearance of Fishy Egmon... We will probably only reach the Italian Restaurant and the Monastery in episode 3.
-
@Drenok
Boni was behind Lamprecht and Cornelius, around 16:45.I didn't see
Rihyarda,Leberecht or Leonore. (At first I thought purple hair behind Hartmut was her, but that's an adult. It could be her mom, I guess?) -
@Almond-Magnum said in Ascendance of a Bookworm - anime discussion:
@Drenok
Boni was behind Lamprecht and Cornelius, around 16:45.I didn't see
Rihyarda,Leberecht or Leonore. (At first I thought purple hair behind Hartmut was her, but that's an adult. It could be her mom, I guess?)Are you sure it's Boni? Ah yea, your right. Somehow he looks younger then what I imagine him to be :D
Rihyarda (Behind Sylvester) and Leberecht (The red haired Scholar behind Florentia, if I am not mistaken): around 16:38
Leonore (if I am correct): Purple haired girl, 3rd row (at around 18:42) -
Wilfried being Wilfried.
So fun to see this part getting animated.
-
Opening music included a frame that was a nod to Attack on Titan? Wait a minute am I watching the right anime? 😆
Just loved the adaptation for this series. Wit definitely did an amazing job!
-
@Drenok said in Ascendance of a Bookworm - anime discussion:
Rihyarda (Behind Sylvester) and Leberecht (The red haired Scholar behind Florentia, if I am not mistaken): around 16:38
Oh, yeah. I wonder if Green Hair next to him is Angelica and Lieseletta's mom?
Leonore (if I am correct): Purple haired girl, 3rd row (at around 18:42)
Could be, but she looks old to be one year younger than Cornelius.
-
@Almond-Magnum said in Ascendance of a Bookworm - anime discussion:
Oh, yeah. I wonder if Green Hair next to him is Angelica and Lieseletta's mom?
That is what I am suspecting.
-
Summary of episode 1:
0:00 R in carriage on the way to her new home
0:22 Summary of backstory.
1:05 back to carriage, but basically still filling in backstory.
2:00 OP
3:40 Arrival at Karstedt's estate.
3:48 Flashback to Cornelius and Elvira discussing the coming of R.
4:34 First meeting with Elvira. The greeting blessing gets over 10 seconds of screen time.
5:48 Coprophagic slime beasts!
5:54 Bathing
5:58 Bad hair day.
6:02 Benno sells rinsham.
6:11 Results of rinsham. Ella serves cookies.
7:20 Ferdinand and Karstedt arrive. R bribed to memorize names.
8:37 Etiquette lessons.
8:50 Cornelius takes R most of way to house bookroom.
9:48 Post collapse aftermath.
9:50 Ferdinand lectures Cornelius on R's health.
10:04 ad break.
10:30 Day before baptism, introduce Eckhart and Lamprecht, who lifts her high up.
(10:41-10:48) flashback to trombe hunt
11:10 Household preparing for baptism. Talking with Eckhard about Ferdinand.
12:09 R dressed for baptism. Ferdinand gives hairstick, R cries.
14:50 Healing R's face.
15:03 Back with Elvira et al.
15:27 The great hall full of people.
15:41 Hartmut gets labelled.
15:53 Rosina gets labelled.
16:00 grand entrance.
16:54 baptism
18:??-18:46 Mass blessing
18:42 Brunhilda seen in crowd
18:57 Syl announces adoption
19:59 Adoption magic
20:20 Food and introductions. Syl's family.
20:49 Damuel and Brigitte.
21:02 Wilfried abducts R.
21:23 R collapses
21:36 "to be continued ... "
21:39 ED. Images recap the backstory with lower city family.
23:09 "next episode"
23:12 end of episode chibis.
23:21 first law of noble etiquette. Karstedt buys two dresses to keep Elvira happy.
23:45 end illustration.OP: What's with the coastal scene? The pop-up-book temple has the orphanage reasonably correct (but with much too little front yard) but the Greek temple with columns in the center is not at all correct. Covers from P1V2 and P2V3 get replicated. Not only has Lessy been in most or all of the trailers, he's in the OP. So that is one would-be-surprise they've chosen to spoil. I'm not sure how commoner-Myne gets to run with Tuuli and Lutz without collapsing. Lutz is really skinny.
I feel that Karstedt's house should have balconies suitable for landing and launching highbeasts. I don't think the manga or LN show these either.
They really like making people climb lots of steps to get to the front door, don't they? The temple does the same. Maybe it is a quirk of Ehrenfest architecture.
The coprophagic slime beast pit is wide with no seat or anything? How is one supposed to use it?
The rinsham sales scene was very short and didn't include the flower patterned paper. And somehow R managed to get her hair shiny again beforehand.
There's no way Ella would be serving cookies to Elvira, but I see the point in taking this opportunity to reintroduce her.
Why does R look sad when Ferdinand has just offered the cathedral library keys as a bribe?
The background at 11:07 is not consistent with the first exterior view we get of Karstedt's house, given that they are meeting at the top of those front steps.
When Lamprecht lifts and shakes R, he's warned about her health, but pays no attention...Meanwhile, Eckhard kneels to be at eye level with her to converse.
R crying over the hairstick gets a good amount of screen time, as it should, for emotional impact.
Ferdinand has the multi-coloured bracelet for doing the crying-face-healing. I don't think he'd be wearing this, nor need it.
The hall they use for the baptism is huge! The crowd looks about the right size (300ish). Nobody gets a seat!
Only three of the god statues seem to have their holy tools.
Hartmut gets introduced with a written label. I didn't expect this, as he isn't relevant until next part. I thought we'd just see him in passing. Brunhilda gets the "see her in passing" treatment, however.
We don't know that R was specifically told to bless everyone.
Sylvester mentions that R was unaware of her noble heritage, but otherwise does not address that she had been "known" to be a commoner.
Wilfried spends 3-4 seconds dragging an unconscious R before he notices.
"to be continued ..." has its ellipsis dots at mid-lowercase-letter height rather than on the baseline. (Undoubtedly there is a typesetting term for this which I don't know.)
Anime (subtitles) uses "upper class noble" instead of "archnoble". Like the LN, "Aub" and "Archduke" are both used. Karstedt's third wife is called "Rosemary" rather than "Rozemary". The temple is called "cathedral".
(Don't expect this much detail from me next week, as I'll be busy visiting family.)
-
@Drenok said in Ascendance of a Bookworm - anime discussion:
Oswald (I could have done without his presence really)
About the only valid reason for his presence is to be used as a doorstop.
-
I like how this episode had so many small things for book readers. They snuck in book covers at OP and important characters as karuta. At ED they have put many scenes from previous book. Things that were left behind. Quite appropreate for ED. First episode fills me with lots of confidence that anime will be really good. You can see lots of love put into this anime.
