Ascendance of a Bookworm - General Discussion
-
@hopebestman said in Ascendance of a Bookworm - General Discussion:
I also wonder one thing. In this world , is there surnames? I mean nobles have family blood , honor and stuff. So maybe at least nobles had family names but i dont remember of hearing Shikza's , Kars' , Damuel's or Ferdinand's family name? If i remember correctly , city got its name from Duke but is it Duke's name or family name i dont remember.
I'm using the Father's name to make the surnames
-
-
@TenmaGirl1990 Gunther points out there is only one noble that can use the Ehrenfest name, the archduke.
-
I'm fairly sure there aren't any surenames in this world except for nobles to a small degree. I believe they just belong to a certain house or something like that.
-
@Heldawn Conveniently, we never see two person with the same first(?) name in this world. Pretty artificial but consider that a reader service.
-
@hiroto said in Ascendance of a Bookworm - General Discussion:
@Heldawn Conveniently, we never see two person with the same first(?) name in this world. Pretty artificial but consider that a reader service.
Considering the High Priest gave the rule that the donated baby could not have the same name as anyone else in the orphanage it spells out surnames aren't a thing.
Surnames is not something we've always had in our history. For a long time we only had first names. To state not having surnames is artificial is unreasonable as it is quite possible that they do not.
-
@Heldawn said in Ascendance of a Bookworm - General Discussion:
To state not having surnames is artificial is unreasonable as it is quite possible that they do not.
What I'm saying is that no two person with the same first name appear in this story, no matter how much Myne's world expands. THAT is quite artificial for the convenience of the author (and the reader).
-
@hiroto said in Ascendance of a Bookworm - General Discussion:
@Heldawn said in Ascendance of a Bookworm - General Discussion:
To state not having surnames is artificial is unreasonable as it is quite possible that they do not.
What I'm saying is that no two person with the same first name appear in this story, no matter how much Myne's world expands. THAT is quite artificial for the convenience of the author (and the reader).
Yes that is probably out of convenience for the reader and author because realistically others would have the same name.
-
@Heldawn I think HIgh Priest just say so because it would be troublesome if in orphanage two kids share the same name... isn't that more make sense?
-
conventions for surnames may also vary between commonors and nobles
there's a reason that nobles have polysyllabic names that sound made up/fantastical : Brezenwast or whatever; so far we haven't seen that they have surnames.
everyone has a unique given name; someone else has one you like (mother/father/ whoever) make a contraction / hybrid out of several other's names
I suspect that commonors do have surnames (but they might be the 'son of" / 'daughter of' variety...and orphans don't even have that)
-
Here is a woman cosplaying Myne playing a harspiel (actually a Ukranian instrument called a bandura.)
-
Does anyone here know if there are sidestories that have never seen print in the light novels or in the currently untranslated bonus books? I might want check the ones that have no hope of ever being translated into English with Google translate at some point.
-
There are bonus books - put out by the original publisher. I understand they are chock-a-block full of art, and maps, and worldbuilding, and spoilers.
I'd love for the content to be premium bonuses, inserted in appropriate places of JNC premiums - or as separate volumes released at appropriate times -
JNC---take my money!
-
@Jon-Mitchell I know. I mean if there are any bonus chapters from the WN that did not end up in either light novels or the bonus books. If they are in the bonus books, I'll wait for the chance that they'll be someday translated into English. If they are nowhere, might as well read them now.
-
ah! well that's an entirely different question. My understanding is that many "bonus" stories (like fan requested POV after stories, in the WNs) do get cleaned up and made part of the LN final product. I don't know the details as to what the differences are between the WN and LN) Sam posts a bonus content list (you can search the forums) and so far all the bonuses for AoaB are textless art. I know that there was a promotional magazine published in Japan as a giveaway to promote a release (and coincided with the anime premiere) - I'd like to see that here someday too
-
I wonder if we will get SS volume after Ark4?
https://play.google.com/store/books/details/?id=rU2nDwAAQBAJ
It says it includes SS from arks 1-4.I don't see there any old SS we already got so I suppose all of those are new content and not a compilation book.
And I see Gunther's PoV stories there, so it should be super good stuff. -
@AlexUsman
The volume contains 21 chapters and the breakdown is:
4 WN versions of chapters that changed or were skipped in the LN (006, 013, 018, 108)
2 event bonus stories
7 chapters from the SS WN (10, 38, 39, 40, 42, 44, 45)
8 TO BOOKS exclusive side-stories (retailer benefit for P3V1, P3V3, P3V4, P3V5, P4V1, P4V2, P4V3, P4V4)Unless it sold poorly we should get more in the future to compile the retailer exclusive side-stories after P4V4
There is also the Gaiden volume set within Part 4 that contained 18 chapters with 10 being LN exclusive and I believe that remaining 8 were from the SS WN.
Chronologically the Gaiden volume came out after P4V4 and the Compilation volume came out after P4V8.
@Jon-Mitchell said in Ascendance of a Bookworm - General Discussion:
I know that there was a promotional magazine published in Japan as a giveaway to promote a release (and coincided with the anime premiere) - I'd like to see that here someday too
Are you talking about this? If so it contains basically nothing. Starts of with characters CVs, followed by the first chapter of the Part 1 manga, and then three chapters from P1V1. Throw in some random promotional adverts and that it's.
-
I realized something. In volume 1, the commoner shopkeeper had a book and he said "he got from a noble until he comes back and pay the bill" or something like that.
Even Damuel, bottom of the noble society didnt go to commoner area. Which noble gave that book as an insurance? Isnt that weird? I mean who carries a book with him and buys something but his money isnt enough so he gives the book IN COMMONER AREA???
-
@hopebestman
I think the noble was poor (for a noble) and pawned the book for cash.Most likely the noble summoned the pawnshop owner to his estate in the nobles quarter. Or possibly he had an attendant go to the shop in his place to carry out the transaction.
-
@b-scot-morgan more interesting thing is, Myne didnt go shoping after that. If she saw the book again, she would buy it :D