Ascendance of a Bookworm - General Discussion
-
Something I've been wondering since way back when I first read the fan translation of the webnovel, up until I was reminded of it again by watching the anime, is exactly why Myne likes books. Not in the sense of "what's her motivation" (since I'm fine with leaving it at "she likes books because that's the plot set up"), but in the sense of which part of "liking books" is the primary cause.
Basically, does Myne like books because of what they contain (ie the "collected wisdom of humanity" mentioned in the opening monologue), or does she like books because of the medium of books and paper?
These are not mutually exclusive, of course. And I'm not going deep into philosophy and (post-)structuralism and media studies and all that. (I had enough of McLuhan in university.) I'm just curious whether Myne would have gone through the whole plant paper thing if, say, her mokkan endeavour had been successful.
Because there is a difference between wanting a book, and wanting the contents of the book. The latter is what Myne seems to value, since a lot of her explanations, both in monologues to the reader/viewer and her talks with Lutz, focus on the ability for information recorded on media to be passed down through multiple people, regardless of whether they personally knew the original creator of that information. Similarly, the "collected wisdom of humanity" bit also implies that Myne's love of books is due to what she reads and absorbs through them, rather than anything inherent to the physical medium of books itself.
However, soon she also starts focusing on paper as the primary way to create books. Now, obviously there are immense advantages to paper as a medium, especially compared to her early efforts like clay tablets. So is her focus on paper books because it's the best (in terms of the historical setting) way to contain the information within a book, or because she actually likes paper books?
Personally I think it's a case where Myne certainly places more emphasis on the contents of a given book, regardless of the medium in which it's presented, eg audiobook or ebook or whatever. However, being from our "modern time" with our very long history of associating writing with books, she also has the mental association where a "true" collection of information would be presented as a book. Hence when she sees a book, she's happy to encounter it, regardless of what is actually written in it. This also applies to her joy at being taught the local alphabet; writing her name over and over isn't particularly useful for imparting information, but it has mental and emotional associations with more complex writing that are.
(If an example helps, I vaguely recall a random episode of Buffy The Vampire Slayer where Giles explains his antipathy to computers: they have no smell, unlike books. So his sensory association of that smell to his love of texts does mean he likes books as a medium, even if they hypothetically have only blank pages inside.)
-
@unsynchedcheese (I mentioned some of this over in the vol 5 discussion I think)
When Myne is going through her past life memories with Ferdinand she mentions that her local library "has even begun to carry dvds and audiobooks". She doesn't seem dismissive of that medium at all. Earlier in vol 5 when Myne is arguing about what a book is with Ferdinand she is annoyed that Ferdinand is focusing on the medium rather than the content itself. Myne has a lots of little throwaway lines like this just dotted around the LN. Unfortunately, Myne is bad at explaining things without doing demonstrations as many of the characters have pointed out.
The type of book Myne advocates are all heavy science and technology books and only nearly as a afterthought she only mentions reading myths and other fiction after those and even then she is stressing that those teach about people in the past.
I'm interested as well in why Myne is obsessed with "books", especially with the subtle religious elements being mentioned, and who exactly Myne is. After rereading the LNs while waiting for vol 6 to start coming out my own theory right now is that Myne is a another iteration of the person/soul who was also Urano and original Myne and simply thinks she is Urano because that past life makes up so much of her memory (rather than a blend of the two or Urano on her own). I'm do have details to back that up, the narrative perspective change by the author going from WN to LN for the prologue separates Urano and Myne whereas the original WN linked them completely. Before she even gets out of bed Myne displays an immediate change of opinion of her actions as Urano mirror her poor opinion of her action/s as original-Myne. Myne seems somewhat guilty/regretful about her actions as Urano/original Myne. Effa's tidbits about original Myne potential dreaming of being people other than Urano. There are lots of little small things that add up on a reread.
(Edit: Shorter version: Myne appears to have a difference perspective on her actions as Urano and Original Myne which in part changes how she acts. It appears less as a person changing than another different iteration, or true self or something, regretting the actions of themselves in a past life)
Then you've got the religious elements that started showing up at the end of vol 3. Otto is teasing Benno about Myne being his "Goddess of Water/Spring" which is a goddess associated with change, new life and new growth and Gunther is taking such talk very very seriously. Gunther is a bit of a oddball in that he sought to become a knight as a child and became a solider as the next closest thing. In such a rigid stagnant society Gunther really stands out in his thinking and his actions also coincide with the traits associated with the Goddess of Water. It makes sense that someone with that type of abstract thinking could make the jump to divine activity given what he knows about Myne by vol 4.
Given the above I reckon the religious elements are going to become more important since it seems Myne's goal isn't to read "books" but to read the technological and scientific output of an advanced culture. In order to do that Myne needs to make drastic changes to society. (Wouldn't be surprised if Myne starts thinking of ways to get right of the High Bishop if he opposes her changing the Church into a place of teaching).
Here is a big question: If "books" to Myne are the "Crystallisation of humanity's knowledge and experience" then what the hell does she actually mean when says "librarian"?
I suspect Myne's definition of librarian will be a key point going forward.
-
@unsynchedcheese
I think Myne loves the experience of reading books. That includes gaining knowledge (in any format), but even more so it includes the pleasure of the process of reading text, as well as the sensory aspects of the feel of a book in her hands and the smell of paper and ink. In the case of books with a narrative component (fiction, history, etc.), there is also the pleasure of being absorbed in the story. I would imagine that all of these are mixed together in her mind.As for how she became this way, who can say? Who knows why people become passionate about the things they do? Since Urano’s father died when she was very young, and the book room in her mother’s house originated with him, perhaps her love of books started due to her father. A way to remain connected to him after he was gone, or something? Adult Urano didn’t seem especially emotional about her father, but child Urano probably felt differently at the time. But that is just guesswork.
-
@rahul-balaggan said in Ascendance of a Bookworm - General Discussion:
This thread is now tagged with “Bookworm”.
Could we also get:
Anime Discussion
Manga Volume 1
Manga Volume 2
Manga Volume 3
Manga Volume 4
Tagged with "Bookworm" if we're not reserving that exclusively for catch-up and LN discussions? -
@lurkingmclurk said in Ascendance of a Bookworm - General Discussion:
if we're not reserving that exclusively for catch-up and LN discussions?
Not at all!
'Tis done!
-
Today is Kazuki-sensei's birthday! :)
https://twitter.com/miyakazuki01/status/1219785247610425344 -
Everyone say high to Kazuki-sensei since apparently she’s looking through the forums :D
https://twitter.com/miyakazuki01/status/1222392495192956929?s=21From readers living in the United States. It seems that the English version is exciting. *** As for J-Novel, the number of people who want to read only "book lovers" and become a member is increasing every day. Discussion topics are set up on the member bulletin board for each volume, but in 2-2, the number of posts exceeded 1,000 at a stretch.
-
@legitpancake said in Ascendance of a Bookworm - General Discussion:
Everyone say high to Kazuki-sensei since apparently she’s looking through the forums :D
https://twitter.com/miyakazuki01/status/1222392495192956929?s=21From readers living in the United States. It seems that the English version is exciting. *** As for J-Novel, the number of people who want to read only "book lovers" and become a member is increasing every day. Discussion topics are set up on the member bulletin board for each volume, but in 2-2, the number of posts exceeded 1,000 at a stretch.
Waves to Kazuki-sensei - "love your story"
-
@legitpancake has anyone told her that if the thread for P2V3 keeps up at the current rate, it will exceed 2000?
-
@jcochran
And it hasn't even reach halfway through the volume yet. -
Hello Kazuki Sensei, I love Bookworm and I hope to keep reading it for years to come.
-
@legitpancake said in Ascendance of a Bookworm - General Discussion:
Everyone say high to Kazuki-sensei since apparently she’s looking through the forums :D
https://twitter.com/miyakazuki01/status/1222392495192956929?s=21From readers living in the United States. It seems that the English version is exciting. *** As for J-Novel, the number of people who want to read only "book lovers" and become a member is increasing every day. Discussion topics are set up on the member bulletin board for each volume, but in 2-2, the number of posts exceeded 1,000 at a stretch.Sorry to disappoint you, but it is kind of misunderstanding you'll get from MTL result. This should be supplemented as "
I heardfroma readerliving in the United States." So, she herself is not watching here, but I'm the one who commented on her syosetu.com status report posting with that information and she kindly tweeted it out. -
Actually, that tweet was a top of a thread. Here is the whole contents:
アメリカ在住の読者様からです。
英語版が盛り上がっているそうです。****
J-Novelも「本好き」だけが読みたくて会員になりましたという人が毎日のように増えてきています。
それぞれの巻ごとにディスカッショントピックが会員掲示板に立てられるのですが、2-2は一気に1000件の投稿数を突破。
それ以前の記録は2年ほど前の594件ですので「規格外」の人気です。
これから二部の後半、三部とどんどん盛り上がっていきますので、掲示板のトップ記録は全て本好きのトピックで埋め尽くされるであろうことは明白。****
……とのこと。
何となく、「なろう」の更新をする度にすごい勢いで感想が来ていて、感想欄に一通り目を通すのも大変だった頃を思い出して懐かしくなりました。笑
英語版も楽しんでいただけているようで嬉しいです。My translation:
I receive the following from a reader living in US.
He says that excitement is growing over the English edition.** QUOTE ***
At J-novel (I have written to her before describing how J-novel system works, with prepubs, forums and memberships, which is very different from traditional translation shop), I see more people joining the forum claiming they came here to just read "Bookworm". J-novel creates discussion topic on the forum for each volume, and the topic for 2-2 blasted past 1000 comments recently.
The previous records has been like 594 comments from a couple years ago, so its popularity is "out-of-ordinary" (here, I used specific expression author uses in the book where Ferdinand uses to describe out of ordinary amount of mana Myne has). I would expect excitement will grow exponentially through the latter part of Part 2 then onto Part 3, it is inevitable that all the top topics will be dominated by the discussion topics for the Bookworm.
*** END QUOTE ***
... so he said.
It remind me of time that whenever I uploaded to "Syosetu", avalanche of comments flowed in and it was very hard for me to just glance through all of them. Makes me feel nostalgic (smile).
I'm glad that people are enjoying the English edition too. -
@jcochran It doesn’t help when many people post multiple single-sentence replies each hour. I wish some users would just combine all their replies each topic into a single comment instead of blasting many short entries within a short period of time like this were a group-text.
-
@hiroto nice. And I suspect that the case with Bookworm is understating things. Right now, the count in P2V3 is 385, assuming it reaches 400 before Monday, it's well on track to blast past 2000. And if P2V2 broke the previous record ....
-
I thought it was cute that somebody responded to that tweet saying (in Japanese) - "I bought the English edition to study English."
-
I guess it makes sense that she can't see the forum, she wouldn't even be able to access it unless she became a subscriber to JNC herself.
-
-
Hi , there. I have a question from Volume 3. In Mark's short story , there is a sentence Benno says
"I’m thinking about starting by going to the city my siblings live in and making a plant paper workshop there too, so I can start the spread of plant paper. Mark. What are you going to do?”
Does that mean , Benno has siblings other than Corrina or he wanted to says kin or relative? Because he mentioned his uncle when he could find sugar for Benno.
Also , i have another question about time/clock. Do we know anything about "xth bell rang" mean? I mean there are examples like
"The gates would open once second bell rang. Farmers who woke up at first bell to come sell their crops, along with merchants who had to spend the night in the villages after the gates closed, would start pouring into the city."
So second bell should be around 5 am or something but do we know are they using 24 or 30 hours a day or totally diffrent system?(just curious about small things)
-
@hopebestman Yes, Benno has more siblings. The short story from the Guildmaster's perspective in the same volume confirms this: "...not only was Benno there, but several of his younger siblings were there too."
Also, from the first volume: "In this city, time was told by the temple's bells ringing every two, three-ish hours." So it doesn't seem like they have touched on anything more specific, but we do know that farmers get up at first bell (which would then logically be around sunrise), while the gates open as second bell (as you noted) and close at sixth bell shortly before sunset in the summer (Lutz's story in the first volume). So assuming a similar day length to Earth (almost 15 hours of daylight at the height of summer), that's roughly every three hours during the day. If they keep to first bell at sunrise and sixth at sunset, then during the winter it would be just a bit under two hours apart. It's probably relative to the length of the day.
