Catchups for March 2020!
-
Just gotta recommend Second Path in Life to everyone! It's a super fun series and totally worth reading. Yea it left a lot of unanswered questions that were never resolved, but it didn't end on a cliffhanger.
-
Oh i can look so to Arifureta so see if it's awful like the anime or not !
Thanks for that and thanks for Realist Hero and the short novels ! -
I second what LegitPancake said about Second Path. It's a great read despite the series being stuck in hiatus. Ditto for Gear Drive. Both have fun, spunky girls as main characters.
-
@legitpancake I really want to know how Fie would be able to get a divorce or annulment once King Roy figures out who Heath is... Or she finds out who Yore is...
-
Great, I really want to give a try to Realist hero, see why it's so popular. Me, a genius also seems like a cool concept.
-
Highly recommend "Walking My Second Path in Life" and "Realist Hero".
Also... this hits 5/6 titles that I initially passed on when they were going up, so I'm nearly qualified to critique the whole catalogue. :P
-
@shiroiryu said in Catchups for March 2020!:
Oh i can look so to Arifureta so see if it's awful like the anime or not !
Thanks for that and thanks for Realist Hero and the short novels !Forget the anime ever existed and enjoy the LN from scratch ;)
-
@legitpancake Sounds a lot like Me, A Genus? Though it ends on a Gear Up scene, the story in the chapter ended, but it started the next chapter's story.
-
Never watched it, but I can see why Arifureta would flop as an anime. It isn't the kind of story that works in a medium with 24 or 48 minute episodes. Same goes for Realist Hero. A story like Ascendance of a Bookworm might be possible, but even that would be a stretch.
Sadly, there is only one title on this month's list for me to pick up. I have either read or am not interested in everything else. But that's somtimes what you get from a semi-free grab bag, so oh well.
-
@piisfun It can work, but only if they don't cut out critical parts of the story rushing ahead. Just 2 examples: the anime basically skipped almost an entire volume in ~3-4 minutes of non-voiced static scenes and it contains the worst CGI scenes I've ever seen (those really ruined it the most for me, even beyond the butchered story).
-
Do Gear Drive and Me, A Genius? reach acceptable stopping points, since we might never get more volumes?
I realize it won't be an ending, but a good pause point is fine.
-
@harmlessdave said in Catchups for March 2020!:
Do Gear Drive and Me, A Genius? reach acceptable stopping points, since we might never get more volumes?
I've read Genius. I wouldn't say that the story felt complete so not a great stopping point, but on the other hand it was relatively short and was a comedy rather than a mystery so it's not like a huge investment of time was betrayed or anything. I still enjoyed what I read would still recommend people check it out despite it ending prematurely.
-
Gear Drive ends with a scene like “and now my journey begins”
But it was not very satisfying to me, It had such a great start and flowed so well till the end of the book.
It left me wanting more.
-
@harmlessdave said in Catchups for March 2020!:
Do Gear Drive and Me, A Genius? reach acceptable stopping points, since we might never get more volumes?
I realize it won't be an ending, but a good pause point is fine.
For Me a Genius?, if you read it up until volume 2 it's kinda alright. But volume 3 ends with a cliffhanger and the author never wrote volume 4 (which was supposed to be the ending).
-
...
Nobody's talking about Occultic;Nine.
I think I'll be reading that and ECHO.
-
@shrike_al said in Catchups for March 2020!:
...
Nobody's talking about Occultic;Nine.
I think I'll be reading that and ECHO.
I couldn't get through ECHO the first time but I too will probably try and read through Occultic Nine.
-
@terabyte said in Catchups for March 2020!:
@harmlessdave said in Catchups for March 2020!:
Do Gear Drive and Me, A Genius? reach acceptable stopping points, since we might never get more volumes?
I realize it won't be an ending, but a good pause point is fine.
For Me a Genius?, if you read it up until volume 2 it's kinda alright. But volume 3 ends with a cliffhanger and the author never wrote volume 4 (which was supposed to be the ending).
I agree, sticking to the first two volumes would help minimise cliffhangers.
-
@xdrfiredogx said in Catchups for March 2020!:
@shrike_al said in Catchups for March 2020!:
...
Nobody's talking about Occultic;Nine.
I think I'll be reading that and ECHO.
I couldn't get through ECHO the first time but I too will probably try and read through Occultic Nine.
KAMERAD!!! *salutes in Russian
I think we're both the same in that case.
-
This post is deleted! -
Now that the volume 6 of Full Metal Panic will be released, will you guys make collector's edition 2?
