Acquisitions Speculation - General
-
@zing The main thing I like about these manga adaptations is that they provide a visual adaptation of the story. This is obviously more relevant for series that don't have anime adaptations yet, but in general, it's nice to have some visuals for the entire story for some.
Of course if I like the manga art style enough that alone is also a reason to read it.
That said, yeah, it basically is there to draw in new people, since manga is an easier point of entry in general.
-
Like some of the others, I'll read the manga adaptations of LN if they are part of the subscription, but normally not otherwise. I am somewhat excited for the Infinite Dendrogram one, though, I'm interested in more depictions of the characters from that story.
Manga are significantly more expensive on the time per dollar scale for me compared to LNs, so I don't read many of them in general. It's hard to justify a manga for a story when there's a more "complete" and money efficient option available in the LNs.
-
I rent my manga from the library.
I buy the occasional one, but usually only if it's a really good deal (cheap Omnibus or something; super cheap on sale). That said, I'll probably read the ones I've read the original work for, and also the manga originals here.
Still, I'd recommend people at least thumb through Ascendance of a Bookworm in case it needs eyes to get the LN license (some speculating they may already have it in the other 5 LN yet to be announced, but I don't want to count my chickens yet). Obviously verbal support on social platforms helps as well.
-
@zing it kind of depends for me, there are a few factors that goes into whether or not I read the manga.
How much do I like the series?
What is new or different about the Manga?
How is the art?
-
I haven't been active on the site for a few months, but this particular topic is one I've given a lot of thought to with regards to my personal preferences. I've noticed that the anime and manga are a lot less entertaining if I've read the LN. For that reason, I tend to avoid manga which I've read the LN of. However, I'll inversely avoid reading the LN of a manga which I'm reading. The reason is the difference in the amount of material covered, and noticeable gaps in the story when alternating between them.
I'm rather adamant about anime, and refuse to skip over a series which I'm interested in. However, I get nowhere near the enjoyment from watching a series which I've read the LN of. Case in point, Smartphone came up in a conversation earlier this week because I noticed that it was a catch-up this month. I originally watched the series before beginning reading the LN, and actually enjoyed it quite a bit. However, as a result of the conversation, ended up re-watching the series yesterday and it was painfully obvious how much of the story had been pushed out of the anime in order to give only a bare-bones "primer" for the story in the anime. In that spotlight, it was hard to see why I had been so hyped about the series. FWIW, I had the same feeling from Ragnarok and How Not to Summon a Demon Lord as some of my favorite scenes from the LNs had been either completely edited out, or edited to barely a mention.
I know this makes it sound like I'm placing a lot of weight on the LN aspect, but a lot more time is required for reading a LN than is required for manga or anime. More often than not, it's spare time that I don't have. For that reason, I'm actually more likely to avoid the LN (after a fair review of the first part) if I know there are other adaptations available.
I'm currently only reading about a dozen manga series, the catch-up of Smartphone, and My Mental Choices are Completely Interfering with my School Romantic Comedy (practicing my Japanese with this one).
I will add that I'm also more likely to read a manga which I've already seen the anime of in order to continue the story. Up to this point, the only LN which I've done the same with are the two I'm currently reading. Otherwise, I nitpick one media or the other to the point that I can't enjoy it. Case in point, I've tried watching Rokujouma at least half a dozen times this year and consistently get sidetracked by something else.
-
Another interesting tidbit from the Curiouscat!
Regarding the 5 series your in discussions for...are any isekai? I love the isekai genre and hope we get lots more.
It should come as no surprise that some are isekai and some are not! One is reverse isekai though.
So there's a reverse isekai title in the mix! I personally have really wanted to see more reverse isekai in the English LN-sphere in general so this is great news to me. As for what that reverse isekai title might be... I'll let those more familiar with what LNs are out there speculate on that.
MAL
Beneath the Tangles (the blog I write for) -
@stardf29 said in New Acquisitions Speculation General [8 NEW AQUISITIONS ANNOUNCED (5 MANGA, 3 LNs)! 2 AQUISITIONS YET TO BE CONFIRMED! IT'S MANGA TIME!!!]:
As for what that reverse isekai title might be... I'll let those more familiar with what LNs are out there speculate on that.
Well... My wishful thinking hopes for this. x)
I Was Summoned to a Different World, But I Was Forcibly Repatriated Back To Japan Because of My Weight, So I Decided To Lose It https://forums.j-novel.club/post/30040
Apparently the definition of reverse Isekai is contentious though, lol. But this one has both the (rejected) hero returning to his world, and a princess being reverse Isekai'd there as well (by accident?).
This one does have a manga adaptation as well that is just starting up (one volume released so far, and it has chapter releases on Bookwalker as well).
-
I'm hoping it's the Overlap title, The Hero's Success is Now! which has caught my interest back when it was announced.
-
@aruseus493 said in New Acquisitions Speculation General [8 NEW AQUISITIONS ANNOUNCED (5 MANGA, 3 LNs)! 2 AQUISITIONS YET TO BE CONFIRMED! IT'S MANGA TIME!!!]:
The Hero's Success is Now!
I love the colors on that cover. =)
-
The only time I read manga is when I accidentally buy them at Yenpress. It’s kinda a waste like someone mentioned IMO since I get less time of entertainment. This has happened to me 4 times now. I’m not sure if I’m to blame for “accidentally” buying manga tho cuz not all their licensed titles does it say “manga” or at least it didn’t when I accidentally bought them.
-
@hyferzftw said in New Acquisitions Speculation General [8 NEW AQUISITIONS ANNOUNCED (5 MANGA, 3 LNs)! 2 AQUISITIONS YET TO BE CONFIRMED! IT'S MANGA TIME!!!]:
The only time I read manga is when I accidentally buy them at Yenpress. I’m not sure if I’m to blame for “accidentally” buying manga tho cuz not all their licensed titles does it say “manga” or at least it didn’t when I accidentally bought them.
This happened to me with Slime. It's sitting on my desk unread. T_T
-
That’s not as bad as the time I was ordering on book depository and ended up with a German copy of a manga.
-
I only read manga if there is no LN available, or if it's known to be markedly different. I prefer LN most of the time.
-
@terrence I binge read slime in like 2 days now I gotta wait for v4 which luckily is out in December 11 but unfortunately have to wait til April for v5. Hopefully the anime doesn’t spoil v4 or 5. I actually like the anime it’s doing a awesome job for now.
-
@hyferzftw Considering that the anime took 8 episodes to do the first book, if they keep that pace, they will only adapt 3 books.
-
@terrence The Slime manga is really great though :o one of the few LN manga adaptations I collect.
-
@myskaros said in New Acquisitions Speculation General [8 NEW AQUISITIONS ANNOUNCED (5 MANGA, 3 LNs)! 2 AQUISITIONS YET TO BE CONFIRMED! IT'S MANGA TIME!!!]:
@terrence The Slime manga is really great though :o one of the few LN manga adaptations I collect.
I'm just bitter about grabbing the wrong thing. T_T
I'll probably read Slime LN next month since the anime is airing now.
-
I wonder when we might see some hints for the new LN announcements?
-
@catstorm it was said in “winter” and it’s still technically fall, so maybe end of the year surprise?
Sorry but J-Novel Club does not publicly comment on any potential licensing decision or acquisitions.
J-Novel Club, Future Volume Release Schedule
Manga FAQ
Premium Content List -
Well isn’t that peculiar summer official starts in Australia on the 1st of December so I just assumed Winter would start on the 1st as well in the north.
