J-Novel Club
    • Categories
    • Recent
    • Tags
    • Users
    • Login

    The English light novel market versus the Japanese light novel market

    Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Light Novel Discussion
    22 Posts 12 Posters 11.3k Views
    Loading More Posts
    • Oldest to Newest
    • Newest to Oldest
    • Most Votes
    Reply
    • Reply as topic
    Log in to reply
    This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
    • P
      paulnamida @Hyferzftw
      last edited by

      @hyferzftw said in The English light novel market versus the Japanese light novel market:

      Aren’t some written on even smaller books than how it is for English speaking countries. That might be another factor but not really cuz that would mean the book is fatter.

      This, most light novels are published as rather small books, the format is called Bunko and are around 600-800 円 (around 6-7 US$). Bigger formats are around 1100-1200 円 (around 10-11 US$). Even then it's still cheaper.

      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
      • Paul NebelingP
        Paul Nebeling Premium Member
        last edited by

        What I'm hearing regarding the price difference is:

        • Cost of licensing
        • Cost of production
        • Higher quality materials
        • Larger format of the book

        The last two really explain the (much?) Luther cost of a printed book over a digital one. The second explains the slight price increase between a Japanese digital book and an English one. I'm thinking the first is minimal.

        I think that my question about demographics may have been poorly worded. I'm pretty sure that Japan has far more publishers of light novels than in the English speaking parts of the world. Some of those publishers cater to certain demographics. That doesn't seem to happen in the English market. Is that because the size of the English market is so much smaller?

        J 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
        • J
          Jaquobus Premium Member @Paul Nebeling
          last edited by

          @paul-nebeling said in The English light novel market versus the Japanese light novel market:

          That doesn't seem to happen in the English market. Is that because the size of the English market is so much smaller?

          Basically this. We have now one publisher targeting a niche, Cross Infinite World for Shoujo LNs. All other publishers are just trying to get whatever might be popular. Even in the manga market in the Anglosphere you only recently got imprints like that one from Seven Seas targeting a certain niche (ecchi in that case).

          If you compare that with the more mature manga markets in France and Germany, you'll find a few more selective providers targeting niches like Seinen, BL and so on. But this can IMHO only happen once there is a baseline demand, which in the case of light novels might not be the case yet.

          You can't spell Keikaku without Kei – Vote for Sagrada Reset!

          1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
          • Shiroi HaneS
            Shiroi Hane Premium Member
            last edited by

            I thought Cross Infinite’s staple was more josei than shoujo, but those demographic labels are generally derived from the magazines that manga run in, so aren’t necessarily applicable to novels unless they are based on manga. Given that novels target a generally older age demographic than manga, the major distinction is whether they are for men or women, and there are labels that cater to both.

            J TerrenceT 2 Replies Last reply Reply Quote 0
            • J
              Jaquobus Premium Member @Shiroi Hane
              last edited by

              @shiroi-hane Actually, I really should have written novels of interest to woman and girls, as that's much closer to the truth.

              As for demographics: There are a few LNs serialized in magazines like Dengeki G's Magazine, which allow classification (Seinen in that case), but I agree that it's generally harder than for manga.

              You can't spell Keikaku without Kei – Vote for Sagrada Reset!

              1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
              • TerrenceT
                Terrence Premium Member @Shiroi Hane
                last edited by Terrence

                @shiroi-hane said in The English light novel market versus the Japanese light novel market:

                I thought Cross Infinite’s staple was more josei than shoujo, but those demographic labels are generally derived from the magazines that manga run in, so aren’t necessarily applicable to novels unless they are based on manga.

                I heard someone call female novels "Otome". Would that ever apply to novels? I thought that's only visual novels.

                I mean, a lot of Shoujo follows patterns you see in Otome + reverse harem, but not all Josei or Shoujo follow those patterns.

                myskarosM 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                • myskarosM
                  myskaros Staff @Terrence
                  last edited by

                  @terrence said in The English light novel market versus the Japanese light novel market:

                  @shiroi-hane said in The English light novel market versus the Japanese light novel market:

                  I thought Cross Infinite’s staple was more josei than shoujo, but those demographic labels are generally derived from the magazines that manga run in, so aren’t necessarily applicable to novels unless they are based on manga.

                  I heard someone call female novels "Otome". Would that ever apply to novels? I thought that's only visual novels.

                  "Otome" as a term exists in contrast to "galge," i.e. male harem games, to describe the genre of female/reverse harem games. It's not exactly "wrong" to call a book an "otome" book, but it invites a different expectation as opposed to using the terms "shoujo" or "josei."

                  Whoever said nothing's impossible never tried slamming a revolving door.

                  H 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                  • H
                    Hyferzftw @myskaros
                    last edited by

                    @myskaros I don’t mind shoujo but when it gets to josei that’s the red flag for me. I don’t mind reverse harems either just no male/male action unless for comedic reasons or just a side character’s love life. I’m not against lgbt just not my cup of tea XD . I’ve seen anime that were Josei and didn’t even know what Josei meant until the male on male action happened made me chuckle but told my self no more josei labled anything.

                    TerrenceT NicoN 2 Replies Last reply Reply Quote 0
                    • TerrenceT
                      Terrence Premium Member @Hyferzftw
                      last edited by Terrence

                      @hyferzftw said in The English light novel market versus the Japanese light novel market:

                      @myskaros I don’t mind shoujo but when it gets to josei that’s the red flag for me. I don’t mind reverse harems either just no male/male action unless for comedic reasons or just a side character’s love life. I’m not against lgbt just not my cup of tea XD . I’ve seen anime that were Josei and didn’t even know what Josei meant until the male on male action happened made me chuckle but told my self no more josei labled anything.

                      Most Josei isn't male x make I think. Just made for an adult female audience publication, whereas Shoujo is younger female audience publication.

                      Was Nana a Josei or Shoujo? That feels Josei. I know Orange had a weird publication where it's both. So Cute It Hurts gets a more explicit label later on. Kids on the Slope feels Josei to me too.

                      And then there's Seinen that feels Josei to me (I guess because of the female main character), like Solanin.

                      H 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                      • NicoN
                        Nico @Hyferzftw
                        last edited by

                        @hyferzftw That's not what Josei means. What you described is supposed to be yaoi, which may play a part in coloring your thoughts on josei. Josei is just opposite to seinen, meaning the demographic of adult women. I've seen amazing josei that were not yaoi, particularly Chihayafuru and Usagi Drop (learning about the manga ending though, I like to think the manga never existed).

                        Avatar by Dae
                        https://www.cardmaker.net/profile/337148-dae/

                        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 2
                        • Sam PinanskyS
                          Sam Pinansky Translators
                          last edited by

                          Print books in Japan are cheaper to produce and distribute.

                          One of the biggest price differences is that for the English speaking market, the book distributor will take 30-50% of the price you pay at the register, but for Japan the distribution is cheaper (maybe 10%?), mainly because the country is smaller.
                          Also, the printing costs are actually cheaper because of the smaller format and near monopoly of the printer (you'd think that would drive prices up, but because Japan is Japan they actually keep prices extremely stable).

                          I think that Japan book prices are rising lately however, as material costs are getting higher and the weaker yen hurts that. I wouldn't be surprised to see bunko price up to like, 900 and tankobon to 1400-1500 in a few years.

                          Another thing to note is that in the west, discounts are standard: you almost never pay full cover price. But in Japan it's far more common to pay the full cover price.

                          So yeah, the cover price in Japan might only be 1000 yen for that tank, and $14 for an english book, but you can get the english one 25% off for only ~$11, making the difference a lot smaller.

                          myskarosM Q 2 Replies Last reply Reply Quote 5
                          • H
                            Hyferzftw @Terrence
                            last edited by

                            @terrence and @nico thanks for the misunderstanding.

                            1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                            • myskarosM
                              myskaros Staff @Sam Pinansky
                              last edited by

                              @sam-pinansky said in The English light novel market versus the Japanese light novel market:

                              near monopoly of the printer (you'd think that would drive prices up, but because Japan is Japan they actually keep prices extremely stable)

                              Yay America! Where we know for a fact that this would never happen because companies already try to screw with us even without monopolies!

                              Whoever said nothing's impossible never tried slamming a revolving door.

                              1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                              • Q
                                Qeh Premium Member @Sam Pinansky
                                last edited by Qeh

                                @sam-pinansky said in The English light novel market versus the Japanese light novel market:

                                Another thing to note is that in the west, discounts are standard: you almost never pay full cover price. But in Japan it's far more common to pay the full cover price.

                                Thats something I also noticed. When I buy english books I never pay the full price. I order them on amazon and got any book at least 1-3 eur cheaper.

                                Which is not normal for half of europe. Here we have something called "fixed book price agreement" where a book never drops lower or goes higher than the offical price (only used books can get cheaper/more expensive). Even 10 years later you would have to pay the full price which is ridiclous.

                                1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                • ShinyS
                                  Shiny Premium Member
                                  last edited by Shiny

                                  Lots of very interesting info and analysis in this thread.

                                  @sam-pinansky said in The English light novel market versus the Japanese light novel market:

                                  Also, the printing costs are actually cheaper because of the smaller format and near monopoly of the printer (you'd think that would drive prices up, but because Japan is Japan they actually keep prices extremely stable).

                                  Perhaps the reason for this is that they use a 'low price nobody else can beat' as the way they maintain their monopoly, i.e. they use their economies of scale to keep their prices below what any start-up rival could charge. Through this approach they gain money not through price gauging the customer but from having a large number of sales (which means a lower profit margin is needed per sale) and through utilising their strong position over their suppliers - they can use their massive buying powers to force suppliers and sub-contractors into very low profit margins, i.e. a buyer's monopoly (also known was a monopsony). In some instances there have been cases of large players pushing suppliers into exclusivity deals or 'preferred customer' agreements that further blocks out new entrants, but I would have expected that such behaviour would be blocked as anti-competitive.

                                  Stay shiny, y'all.

                                  1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                                  • TerrenceT
                                    Terrence Premium Member
                                    last edited by

                                    The special digital sales on Bookwalker are so good. 300-600 yen for certain volumes. Of course, JNC pretty competitive there too when their 7 dollar titles go on the infrequent sale.

                                    Paul NebelingP 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                    • Paul NebelingP
                                      Paul Nebeling Premium Member @Terrence
                                      last edited by Paul Nebeling

                                      @terrence That's just a bit under 800 Yen. Not bad.

                                      Edited because... Autocorrect

                                      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                      • 1
                                      • 2
                                      • 1 / 2
                                      • First post
                                        Last post