Novel pick-up requests
-
@rahul-balaggan said in Novel pick-up requests:
From Curious Cat
jnovelclub
I browse it sure. But there is a lot of people just posting cool covers which isn’t really a convincing suggestion.That'd be me (well, I'm evolving a bit, but I still try to avoid plot spoilers if I can before I read, so I definitely go based on either art, the title, or if those aren't illuminating, the synopsis).
But it does seem like he's challenging us to do real in depth recommendations. I need to check what I've done for the ones I've actually read.
I read a healthy portion of the WN (about 21 parts; I'd say, give or take, 50 pages of an LN maybe) for this one recently since it is a "completed" light novel...
"I do not need cheat in the new game!"
"ニューゲームにチートはいらない！"
https://bookwalker.jp/de34fdf246-f833-4706-ad7c-4f02567f8ebe/?acode=WpfPW3yk
...but I don't know if I recommend it (I probably won't read more unless it comes stateside).
The Basics:
So, despite that broken English Google title, it's actually not an Isekai. The main dude starts as a 70+ year old on the last days of his life. He's been training to fight the shadows of demonic gods that leak out of shrines his whole life. He was never blessed with magic, so he was never one to get sent out to fight the biggest baddies or do major quests, which bums him out. Somehow or another he reincarnates as the 20 year old you see (he literally is birthed from a hole in his original body, and the OG body continues to exist as a corpse). He assumes a similar name for himself and iirc he pretends he is the disciple of his previous... body.
So here's some stuff:
Romance - It's decently fun. The female character you see on the cover is Bianca, a prostitute who our main character really wants to free (you need a tremendous amount of money to free people) and have live with him. I fear it goes harem, but I haven't read long enough to know for certain.
Explicitness - It's not that explicit. Sure, characters have relations, but there's no real description of what's going on in the bedroom. So yeah, tame from what I recall.
Battles - The battles are decent. Our hero is basically fighting gods, gods with physical and agile prowess. Our main character's big ability is his
Scale - Really small. Like, it feels like everything is a stone's throw away, and the setup really seems small (there's shrines built for the gods and he has to destroy the gods that leak out of them). I think this is really the thing that is bringing it down for me. And it's so structured (there are 3 shrine gods that our hero has to defeat; maybe there will be a twist once he defeats them all, but yeah, small in scope and super structured). I'm sure there's some stuff to switch this up, but I don't know that it'll become a massive story when it is only 3 volumes (I read through about 21 of the prepub parts, which gets you through the first major battle).
-
I started out describing why I want certain series (I even talked about what sort of series I think could work for JNC, eg. short story/episodic series) but then before I knew it I kinda turned into the Posting Covers.
@Aruseus493 already described the series I posted recently, but I like to post series that at least to me seems like they may be more Slice of Life and the three I posted do seem like they would be like that.
-
Maybe we should get some sort of Format for these, like Reasons why on the top, the title and cover, and if we have multiple titles then they all should be clearly connected somehow that is easy to understand.
-
I used to post LN requests here a while back but then I had an epiphany and that was, I just wanna read light novels.
Don’t matter what genre or what story, as long as it is good (and for the most part I assume anything any foreign company would license would have to be good to a degree)
Literally every single Light Novel mentioned here is a Light novel I wanna read and would be happy to buy and read. (I am assuming no one said Lance N' Masques I don’t ever wanna see that licensed...)
So now I am in a place in my Light novel reading life where I will just kick back and relax and wait for more novels to read, whatever comes comes and I have no control over what that may be...
-
If we're talking about format, I've been going with:
Title
Publisher
Synopsis
Explanation Why I Want It
Cover
@Rahul-Balaggan I'm kind of the same way in wanting to read pretty much most stuff. I actually tend to read so much though that I end up with gaps. So I tend to bug for more licenses so I have more stuff to read. My goal is to have a volume for every day of a month.
-
I usually go
Title
Cover
Publisher
Then either talk about the story or why I want it or bothI even try to reply to every license that interests me
But...Kinda feeling outta the place lately with all Isekais and fantasies so haven't reacted much recently...But the thing is it's manly people throwing their titles here without much interaction...
-X posts title
=Y Upvotes it
-Y posts title
and so on
How can Sam or anyone tell if enough people here are interested in the said title?Like JNC is the only company that deals Bungeishunjū and Kodansha LIGHTNOVEL (aside from Vertical)
So JNC is like the only publisher I can expect being able to get some of the stuff I am interested in -
Maybe we should just start making individual threads for every request?
-
@aruseus493 there would be so many threads. maybe certain genres of some other kind of category. or we can create threads for titles that get recommended alot.
-
@aruseus493
We kinda have to sell our own requests to the people here (Kinda envy people who want more popular titles) before Sam and I don't think swamping the forum with different threads will help that. -
@aruseus493 said in Novel pick-up requests:
Maybe we should just start making individual threads for every request?
If it's an in depth request for a title you know a lot about, I think that may be a good idea. Do a "Why You Should Pick Up (Insert Title): In Depth Reasoning" or something, lol. I can do two of those at some point (Zoa Hunter and Attacking the Dungeon with My Boss is OT Work).
We can still use this one to try and generate interest in stuff we don't know much about. Like if we see a new series pop up with not much info known, but there's no fan scene for it yet, just to kick the ball around a bit.
Like I saw this Earth Star published one pop up recently. I'm planning to look at the Syosetu a bit.
"If You Request a Hero, We Send Him"
https://bookwalker.jp/de11476abe-4a5e-45b2-a551-f6cad8b33f08/?acode=WpfPW3yk
I wouldn't do an individual thread on this because, well, it's new, I'm not going to read the synopsis so I can keep my impressions to what I see (the cover and title kind of speaks for itself; elf girl, human dude, and human girl work at an office that dispatches a Hero in exchange for rewards).
-
So many popular light novel series mentioned on this thread, and yet I’ve only seen JNC start translating light novels that are barely mentioned from posts I’ve read from when I first joined. As more time passes, the number of volumes for those series are increasing.
-
@kite-xx said in Novel pick-up requests:
So many popular light novel series mentioned on this thread, and yet I’ve only seen JNC start translating light novels that are barely mentioned from posts I’ve read from when I first joined.
There was one Nostradamus who had a lot of his LN requests, in a short period of time, picked up. I believe Unwanted Undead Adventurer was a part of his recs.
I'm being captain obvious, but yeah, a lot of the popular stuff is Kadokawa properties that won't be a possibility until something drastic happens (which may never happen).
But I also hope I'm not alone in not wanting them to just go down the line and pick all the popular works. We'd probably be even more inundated with fantasy if they did, and you wouldn't get some of the more unique titles we've gotten (I hope we always get some oddball stuff no one could have guessed; if Sol Press doesn't do well, we may not have another pub competing in the marketplace picking up stuff that isn't Kono Light Novel Ga Sugoi acclaimed or has an anime adaptation).
-
Chivalry of a Failed Knight
This series has a really good romance and fanservice is also for the characters. The action and Battles are really good and there are some emotional and physical stakes. The 1V1 battles are really awesome, and the fanservice part is really well done as said before the fanservice is also for the characters too.
In a time and place where one’s soul can be morphed into a weapon, there are modern-day magicians called Mage-Knights. Although Kurogane Ikki is a student at an institution that trains Mage-Knights, he has no particular talent in magic and is labeled the “Failure Knight” or “Worst One.” Getting way less than average marks in the scorings, he was forced to repeat a year. But with the arrival of a new head of the institution, a new rule was created: knights whose abilities are compatible, as decided by the board, must share rooms and attend practice and training together throughout their school years to bring up their abilities to the max. It is a rule to implement the absolute verdict of ability.
Ikki’s roommate, Stella Vermillion, turns out to be a princess of another foreign country. Stella is a Rank A knight: the type of genius in magic who only appears once a decade. When Ikki walked in on her while she was changing her clothes, it caused a huge misunderstanding, which eventually ended up in a duel between the two of them. The punishment for the losing side is Eternal Submission to the winning side.
Forced to live the same room and practice magic together throughout all their school years, how will Stella and Ikki’s relationship evolve?
-
Heyyyy. Didn't Sam mention a twintail he's working on licensing?
God, it'd be nice if it was Chivalry. :)
-
@dtta I think at this point Chivalry of a Failed Knight could have its own thread.
-
@drone205 I'm actually watching that anime right now. It's alright so far, but I especially like the romance.
If J-Novel were to license Chivalry (although I'm not sure who publishes it or if JNC has any connections to them), my only problem is that literally every cover of the volumes look exactly the same. -
@legitpancake SB Creative aka SoftBank
They don’t like digital only (at least the was the word going around back when JNC was founded)
Sorry but J-Novel Club does not publicly comment on any potential licensing decision or acquisitions.
J-Novel Club, Future Volume Release Schedule
Manga FAQ
Premium Content List -
@legitpancake well it aint a Harem and it focuses on the romance between Ikki and Stella, so it makes sense for the covers to focus on her as well. series where a different girl is in each cover are more than likely Harem series that does not have a singular focus romance.
-
@bloodygaikotsu said in Novel pick-up requests:
But the thing is it's manly people throwing their titles here without much interaction...
-X posts title
=Y Upvotes it
-Y posts title
and so on
How can Sam or anyone tell if enough people here are interested in the said title?
Like JNC is the only company that deals Bungeishunjū and Kodansha LIGHTNOVEL (aside from Vertical)
So JNC is like the only publisher I can expect being able to get some of the stuff I am interested inThis is why I want to do some kind of event to not only get people to talk about potential licenses, but also encourage some interaction between forum goers and gauge how popular certain titles or genres are. This will give everyone more information and it's better than just randomly posting titles/covers ad nauseum with no discussion.
I'll try to get something going by tomorrow! Keep your eyes peeled!
-
@myskaros said in Novel pick-up requests:
@bloodygaikotsu said in Novel pick-up requests:
encourage some interaction between forum goers and gauge how popular certain titles or genres are. This will give everyone more information and it's better than just randomly posting titles/covers ad nauseum with no discussion.I'll try to get something going by tomorrow! Keep your eyes peeled!
I had a similar idea to this, I was going to create a poll about peoples favourite Genres/tags but decided to create more focus poll on each genre/tag/topic, the first one was for Isekais. was going to create a new poll for a new genre/tag/topic every few day, up to a week at most.
