J-Novel Club
    • Categories
    • Recent
    • Tags
    • Users
    • Login

    Chaos;Child Children's Revive

    Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Licensing Suggestions!
    41 Posts 31 Posters 16.9k Views
    Loading More Posts
    • Oldest to Newest
    • Newest to Oldest
    • Most Votes
    Reply
    • Reply as topic
    Log in to reply
    This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
    • Sam PinanskyS
      Sam Pinansky Translators @Microdynames
      last edited by

      @microdynames type moon isn’t comporable and you know it. And I might mention that even if it was, how many of the light novels do we have in the West yet? Oh right, zero. And almost none of the manga.
      Spinoffs of franchises are difficult sells even for huge ip like type moon. You are making my point.

      MicrodynamesM 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
      • MicrodynamesM
        Microdynames Premium Member @Sam Pinansky
        last edited by Microdynames

        @sam-pinansky said in Chaos;Child Children's Revive:

        @microdynames type moon isn’t comporable and you know it.

        Yes, I agree completely and said as much, and it was only an argument on principle alone. I haven't watched or played any of the Chaos series myself so I have no personal stake in this topic.

        With that said, if you were of a mind to try to break the trend and go for some Type Moon light novels on the basis of them being the spinoffs least likely to lose money, that would be cool, yeah?
        ヽ(´▽`)/

        _ 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
        • _
          _08 @Microdynames
          last edited by

          @microdynames said in Chaos;Child Children's Revive:

          it was only an argument on principle alone

          What kind of principle? C;C anime isn't that popular and anyone who watched it and wants more would read VN (because everyone would tell them it's much better and there's an English TL). Type-Moon is very popular and (English-speaking) people don't have much good options to read VNs, so they are more likely to read LNs if someone localizes them. That's like a total opposite of C;C case. Might as well bring Edge of Tomorrow as an example. On a principle alone.

          MicrodynamesM 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
          • MicrodynamesM
            Microdynames Premium Member @_08
            last edited by Microdynames

            @_08 said in Chaos;Child Children's Revive:

            @microdynames said in Chaos;Child Children's Revive:
            What kind of principle?

            The principle that a popular enough anime can displace the original VN as an entry vector to spinoffs, so not "ONLY people who played the VN" might be interested.

            C;C anime isn't that popular

            Absolutely.

            and anyone who watched it and wants more would read VN

            Absolutely.

            Type-Moon is very popular and (English-speaking) people don't have much good options to read VNs, so they are more likely to read LNs if someone localizes them.

            Absolutely.

            That's like a total opposite of C;C case.

            Absolutely.

            Might as well bring Edge of Tomorrow as an example. On a principle alone.

            It might make mediocre sales in the mass market if you called it Edge of Tomorrow and put Tom Cruise on the cover, but that sort of disrespect for the original product would seriously offend the core LN base.

            To reiterate I didn't say that C;C should be licensed on a principle, I only said that a VN isn't the only point of entry for "books like this" (i.e.. VN spinoffs). If you want my Chaos;Child specific opinion, I have already said in black and white that I don't think C;C anime reached these lofty heights. I just don't think the statement that "The problem with books like this is that ONLY people who played the VN would be interested," applies to ALL "books like this".

            Perhaps what I really wanted to say was, "I hope you will consider Type Moon novels and not discount them for the same reasons as Chaos;Child CR".

            Sam PinanskyS 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
            • Sam PinanskyS
              Sam Pinansky Translators @Microdynames
              last edited by

              @microdynames I get your point and the reason I’ve hesitated to go after them is more about the complicated licensing situation and how expensive I expect the character rights from aniplex would be.

              MicrodynamesM 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
              • MicrodynamesM
                Microdynames Premium Member @Sam Pinansky
                last edited by Microdynames

                @sam-pinansky It's gratifying to know that such novels have at least been under consideration, thank you for your reply.

                I do hope that some day, complex rights ownership situations notwithstanding, something could be worked out for spinoff novels for established franchises; whether that would be Fate series, Steins;Gate series (the actual Steins;Gate, not the less well received Sci Adv entries), Muv-Luv series or others.

                If only to try and expand the market past the core isekai fantasy and LitRPG diehards. That being said I'm sure you've already thought of that possibility or you wouldn't have acquired Occultic Nine at all.

                Sam PinanskyS 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                • Sam PinanskyS
                  Sam Pinansky Translators @Microdynames
                  last edited by

                  @microdynames Well, Occultic;Nine was more just a matter of good timing. It was a property from Overlap which was a launch partner, it had an anime airing WHEN we launched, and seemed like something that could be popular.
                  But a very difficult episode 1 turned away the majority of the viewership, and we didn't get volume 1 out until after the anime had finished airing.
                  It's been one of our poorest selling books, volume 3 as an example had 21 preorders on Amazon. 21.
                  Compare that to preorders for the latest smartphone or realist that are 2000+.

                  MicrodynamesM 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                  • MicrodynamesM
                    Microdynames Premium Member @Sam Pinansky
                    last edited by

                    @sam-pinansky So what that means is that, in order to prove that the Chaos;Child sequel is viable, the activists requesting its licensing should cast a proxy wallet vote by purchasing 2000 copies of Occultic Nine. :^)

                    Sam PinanskyS 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                    • Sam PinanskyS
                      Sam Pinansky Translators @Microdynames
                      last edited by

                      @microdynames I didn't say that. Nope. Not me. Definitely didn't say that.

                      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 2
                      • S
                        sourgout
                        last edited by

                        I support this 100%

                        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                        • myskarosM myskaros referenced this topic on
                        • 1
                        • 2
                        • 3
                        • 1 / 3
                        • First post
                          Last post