Regarding missing/modified titles from Amazon
-
@myskaros said in Regarding missing titles from Amazon:
@Flinkly Yes, only images have been removed, and they can be viewed at the webpage linked above. And this only affects the books on Kindle, other stores have the full, unaltered book.
So to confirm, are images are removed or have they been moved to the back of the books of affected titles? I am confused by that.
-
@bloodthirstybeast said in Regarding missing titles from Amazon:
So to confirm, are images are removed or have they been moved to the back of the books of affected titles? I am confused by that.
Both and/or neither, depending on storefront and series. Repeating what has been said before....
@myskaros said in Regarding missing titles from Amazon:
Images being put in the back is a permanent workflow change. While we have removed the images we believe to be in violation of Kindle's content guidelines, it was ultimately a judgment call and not based on an exhaustive list of criteria. Putting the images in the back helps reduce the chance of future books being reported based on the sample preview. There are also other fringe benefits that have been discussed elsewhere.
As stated previously, series will be consistent moving forward, so only new series and affected series mentioned above will have images put in the back. Unaffected, ongoing/completed series will keep images in the front.Or put succinctly: New and already affected series are moving all front matter images to the back on all storefronts, with some of those images being removed outright on Amazon's storefront and uploaded at the page linked to in the topic post.
-
@bloodthirstybeast Existing books that have already been released have had some images removed, only on Kindle. The images that were removed can be viewed at the webpage linked in the first post.
New series will have images placed in the back of the book. Some existing series will also have images moved to the back of the book. Ongoing, unaffected series will still have images in the front.
-
@myskaros Any word on what the plan is going to be for volumes where it appears as though the cover illustration may be too spicy for amazon?
Also I don't think it's covered, but is there anything in the amazon versions to indicate to the reader that there is content removed? I realize you've mentioned you can't link to the actual removed content site, but how will amazon buyer be aware there's anything to look for?
-
@jpwong All I can say is we are working on it.
For removed illustrations, the only indication is the EPUB version number.
-
@myskaros "Amazon EXCLUSIVE!"
Don't have to say WHY it's exclusive to Amazon, or what's exclusive about it, so who could complain? Right? -
@SomeOldGuy While I can appreciate the ingenuity, I expect that it would backfire, because some people would take "exclusive" to mean that it's better in some way. It's unlikely that anyone would take it to mean that it's worse. Only those who already know about the situation would know that, and they'll be wary of buying the books from Amazon at that point anyway.
-
@Kalessin Oh, but the Amazon Exclusive IS "better" in one way: it lacks the problematic pictures!
I still think that the AE versions need a disclaimer somewhere:
This book has been modified from its original version. It has been modified to fit this screen and edited for content.
-
@Kalessin - I'm in the "hates minor spoilers" camp so I do prefer images to be either inline or at the back.
-
@Zehd IIRC, myskaros (or someone else from JNC) previously either stated that they aren't allowed to do that or that they were worried that they'd get in trouble with Amazon if they did. It would be nice if they could make it clear that they'd had to remove content for the Kindle version, but they have to be careful, or the books won't be on Amazon at all, which will really hurt them, since far too many people buy from Amazon instead of directly from JNC or from one of the alternatives.
Also, my guess is that unless they had the information in the listing's title, most people would never notice anyway. Most people aren't going to read the descriptive text beyond maybe book 1, and if the note is in the book itself, it's already too late by the time they see it.
JNC is doing their best, but I seriously question that there's actually a way to handle this issue in a way that makes it clear that the book has been altered without it causing problems. And since it's Amazon, sadly, JNC can't afford the problems.
-
@Kalessin And that, kids, is why antitrust laws are not only necessary, but require robust enforcement.
-
Basically, all these changes will affect only Amazon versions of Light Novel. Other eBook sellers, including novels available at Premium here will be unchanged, I've understood this correct?
-
@WarStalkeR said in Regarding missing titles from Amazon:
Basically, all these changes will affect only Amazon versions of Light Novel. Other eBook sellers, including novels available at Premium here will be unchanged, I've understood this correct?
Not quite: https://forums.j-novel.club/post/97845
-
I made a post a week or so ago inbthe sugedtions page asking if JNC would offer there premium ebooks in the mobi format and let us link are device email to are JNC account so that we can have are books just sent straight to are device with out having any extra steps involved. I agree that the customer should not have to do anything extra to get what they paid for. It would make sense going forword for JNCZ as it would make there premium ebooks easy for everybody to get on there device and not just people who are good with tech. Its allready annoying enough to have to go to my phone to buy my books over the device itself. I dont have a pc. I know it should be possible to do on my phone but this thing is oooold. Like 6 or 7 years old
-
@Apairon said in Regarding missing titles from Amazon:
I agree that the customer should not have to do anything extra to get what they paid for.
I just want to point out that people who are paying for DRM-free ebooks from J-Novel Club, are in fact getting DRM-free ebooks from J-Novel Club.
The fact that Amazon does not support ePub files while all other major eReaders and reading apps (iBooks, Google Play Books, Nook, MoonReader)
do, is Amazon making their customers do extra work to use their services and products.I should also make clear that your suggestion for .MOBI files is a perfectly valid suggestion that I take no fault with.
I understand that people who use kindle have to do extra steps to get J-Novel Club files on a kindle, however that really is an Amazon issue with them making their service not user friendly.
-
I do have a question: what is the estimate to get the affected titles back up on the amazon site?
Also, i really appreciate everything the J-novel staff does. The physical media, and creation and support of all the types and outlets of digital media. I'm happy to get what we get, and appreciate it all.
-
@Flinkly said in Regarding missing titles from Amazon:
I do have a question: what is the estimate to get the affected titles back up on the amazon site?
At this time, we unfortunately do not have a solid estimate.
-
@Rahul-Balaggan im sorry if i offended or made upset anyone with my comment. It was not my intent to say that JNC is making me do more work. Im not good at explaining myself over forums so i dont usualy make posts. I mearly wanted to ask if 1 we could get mobi format with out needing a 3rd party programe and 2 if it would be possible to link are device email to are JNC account so we could just send the correct format to are devices. It would be a more user friendly way for customers to buy direct from JNC as not everybody is good with tech. Thats what i mean by extra steps. This would imho be a good way for JNC to make a premium memebership more apealing to a wider group of people. In closing again im sorry if my original post ruffled some feathers. This was not my intent
-
@Apairon I don't think that you've offended anyone. Rahul's main point seems to be simply that the problem is caused by the fact that how Amazon operates is not user-friendly and that JNC is doing exactly what they said they would - provide DRM-free e-books (and in an open format used by everyone but Amazon which is objectively superior to Amazon's format no less). If Amazon were behaving in a more user-friendly manner, then this wouldn't even be an issue. You would be able to just read DRM-free epub files with your Kindle.
Based on Rahul's response as well as what Sam said in another thread, I think that it's clear that JNC will at least consider providing an option to download their premium editions in a format that works with Kindle in the future. However, for now at least, it's just going to be epub files, and if you want them on your Kindle, then you'll have to deal with the file conversion one way or another. And given how slow JNC tends to be with making technical changes, my guess is that it will be a while before you're able to download something other than an epub file even if they do decide that they want to make that change. Either way, it looks like they will at least consider your request.
-
No worries, I took no offense, I just wanted to reply to that one point.