Get Up to Date with September Catchups!
-
@saffire said in Get Up to Date with September Catchups!:
Secret Org is the most unjustly cancelled series to ever exist. I love this story.
Hmm... I read the first volume and it seemed like it had a good premise and approach... but also that it had no idea what it wanted to really do with any of it once things were setup. I'd be tempted to read the second volume, but if it's cancelled and not competed it's hard to justify spending the time.
DLR seems like one of those series I'd either really enjoy or really hate. That particular setup doesn't seem to leave much room for indifference.
-
@pcj That description of characters with powers reminds me of Chrono Trigger, except Marle isn't Chuuni.
-
@xdrfiredogx said in Get Up to Date with September Catchups!:
Hmm... I read the first volume and it seemed like it had a good premise and approach... but also that it had no idea what it wanted to really do with any of it once things were setup. I'd be tempted to read the second volume, but if it's cancelled and not competed it's hard to justify spending the time.
I mean, I can't promise that everyone will love it, but it's been done for years and it's still one of my favorite series on the site. If your concern is "what are they going to do once things are set up", Volume 2 tackles that with a vengeance.
-
Regarding Secret organization, do we get at least some closure at the end of volume 2? It makes me curious, but if it ends with all the plot threads still hanging, or even in a cliffhanger it would be frustrating.
-
@saffire That certainly sounds promising... How much of a cliffhanger I climbing out on if there is no volume 3 though?
-
@lex said in Get Up to Date with September Catchups!:
Regarding Secret organization, do we get at least some closure at the end of volume 2? It makes me curious, but if it ends with all the plot threads still hanging, or even in a cliffhanger it would be frustrating.
There's enough of a hook to get you to come back for volume 3, but it's not really a cliffhanger, per se.
Volume 1 ends with what pretty much feels like closure (it became slice of life by that point). Volume 2 introduces a new character, and most of that volume is about integrating the new character into the group. The ending is a major paradyme shift in the way the organization operates, and it felt to me like a sufficient ending to leave you wondering where it would go from there but not feeling like you're completely hanging. Though I really do want to know where it goes from there. :-) There were also a few side stories at the end that gave an outsider perspective to what was going on (and some touching family moments for the PoV character).
-
@pcj thanks...I'll read the other catchup series first and then if I have enough time left I'll try this one too.
-
@saffire said in Get Up to Date with September Catchups!:
Secret Org is the most unjustly cancelled series to ever exist. I love this story.
This. Very much this (or perhaps Second Life)
-
@caerold Second Path doesn't count anymore, it actually got vol.3 under different publisher in Japan this spring after almost 5 year hiatus.
https://bookwalker.jp/def290d900-5f80-4673-b818-a187ba5a1a42/ -
Yep, now we wait for JNC to get the rights. It's been 6 months, but it being from a publisher JNC has never worked with before and that publisher being rather brand new and may not prioritize international licensing, plus the fact that the original translator no longer works for JNC, all aren't making it any faster.
-
@wellwisher Holy heck, really? That's darn fine news!
-
Thanks for putting Fushi no Kami on catchup. It's a series that's been on my radar for a while due to people saying it's like bookworm.
I read the first volume and came to the conclusion that any resemblance to bookworm is superficial and that the series really is not for me. But now I know and that's a mystery resolved for me.
-
@moonpie - that's what I like about catch up months, I can take more chances on series that I'm not sure about. Being able to read up to a whole volume is much better than a tiny sample from Amazon.
I've found many series thanks to it, and also some that really aren't my cup of tea. LIKE WATARU EVEN THOUGH HE HAS MANY FANS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!one!
(And it's not about a series being "good" or "bad" -- I like what I like, and I don't enjoy some series that are considered quite good by others.)
-
@moonpie said in Get Up to Date with September Catchups!:
Thanks for putting Fushi no Kami on catchup. It's a series that's been on my radar for a while due to people saying it's like bookworm.
I read the first volume and came to the conclusion that any resemblance to bookworm is superficial and that the series really is not for me. But now I know and that's a mystery resolved for me.
it's clearly modeled after bookworm though. It's just only about 1/4 as good. So, a normal LN.
-
@poisonedbite If I had to describe FnK by reference to bookworm, I would say: Bookworm, but an adolescent power fantasy.
But really, I wouldn't compare them at all. Even if they start from similar premises, the interests of the authors diverge so wildly the two series end up having very different appeals (though I accept there might be overlap in their audiences).
-
@harmlessdave Hear, hear. It's a great service!
-
Hello catchup readers! Friendly reminder that catchups will be changing on Friday, October 1, around or after 1000 PDT (1700 UTC), so get your reading done before then!
