J-Novel Club
    • Categories
    • Recent
    • Tags
    • Users
    • Login

    Going to start writing a LN soon! What your thoughts on what I’ve got so far?

    Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Light Novel Discussion
    light novelwritingisekaiharemfantasy
    16 Posts 7 Posters 5.4k Views
    Loading More Posts
    • Oldest to Newest
    • Newest to Oldest
    • Most Votes
    Reply
    • Reply as topic
    Log in to reply
    This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
    • Drone205D
      Drone205 Premium Member
      last edited by Drone205

      I agree with what myskaros says. I think ditching either Isekai or Going to the future would be best. maybe you could just create a character that was just born in this world and when he is a teenager (maybe on a coming of age ceremony) have him and his twin sister sent to the future. This way you have 1 core gimmick instead of 2 loose gimmicks. You can even play with the whole 5000+ yr passage thing like maybe the world devolved into a dark age (maybe due to the dragon) or it progressed really far.

      edit: I think The Faraway Paladin can be a good series to take inspiration from. It is similar to your original Synopsis in some ways like the Reincarnation, but one difference is that Will was raised with the knowledge from centuries ago like the with the Religious ceremonies.

      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
      • TerrenceT
        Terrence Premium Member
        last edited by Terrence

        I have an Isekai idea too (the character archetypes I want to use work better in Isekai; I want the MC to be a bit self-aware of the archetypes from manga / anime at the start, and have preferences for certain ones over others).

        My internal debate is not "is it necessary he is from the real world", but "is it necessary I open with / show the real world" and how much do I show. Faraway Paladin really doesn't show reality.

        Of course, I haven't taken my pen to paper, this is just an idea, and ideas are cheap as they say. It's the execution that is key. I'd love to turn this into a visual novel with like VN Maker. I'll let you guys know if I ever do anything worth mentioning, though likely I'll just keep this on the burner forever (I'd like to learn some simple character creation / sprite tools, or how to create art and how to manipulate it in Live 2D).

        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
        • woodssaayyW
          woodssaayy @myskaros
          last edited by

          @myskaros, true. I’ve got the from Earth there basically as a reference for how he has knowledge and basis of common sense that we have here in stead of the other worlds and he will have to learn the new worlds common sense. Also I have it there because the magic in the story is basically elemental magic (EG: Fire, Earth, water, wind & Holy | High Human race royal family members can use all, giving off the OP MC feel). So with the knowledge and understanding from 21st century Earth were he was an honours student he can use that knowledge of the elements to visual create them (High humans can directly control elements and humans cannot).

          myskarosM 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
          • woodssaayyW
            woodssaayy
            last edited by

            Here’s what I got for a draft:
            Huh... White, just white... I turn my head from left to right but there’s nothing but whiteness and I can’t even differentiate between the ground and walls...

            [Well, well. It seems your awake] ?

            [May I ask whom this is?] Ayata

            [I am an existence which your people would call a ‘God’] God

            A ‘God’ huh... So, I guess since I’m here that means I died.... The last thing I remember was waiting at the traffic lights and then hearing a loud bang but I can’t remember anything after that noise..

            [It seems that the cause of your death was being hit by truck...] God

            Hmm, if I was just hit by a truck then why am I here?? Shouldn’t I be being processed like everybody else to see wether or not I can go to heaven or hell?? Or there are no such places and the theory of reincarnation happens to be true and I’m about to be reincarnated??

            [It would seem you are wondering why you are here. Firstly I would like to apologise for my underlings carelessness which indirectly caused your death] God

            [So It was something like that huh... Almost like the Light Novels and Manga I read as a teen] Ayata

            [Well, your rather calm for one that just learnt that they have died] God

            [Ahaha, true, true. Well I guess I’m the type that accepts things as they are easily, especially this predicament here] Ayata

            Well, I guess it’s true I’m way too calm. Well, I did read a lot of Light Novels and Manga with the MC having similar situations to the one I’m in now... I guess that has a part to play in my calmness and me knowing that I’m not hallucinating or dreaming this up after the incident..

            [Well, I suppose I shall transport your conciseness into its new body which is about to be born] God

            [Wouldn't I get some cheat ability or something??] Ayata

            Well I guess that ‘God’ isn’t obligated to give me a cheat ability as it the incident wasn’t directly caused by him. Damnit I’m a moron shouting that out, I’m lucky enough I’m getting a second chance at life...

            [Haha, do not worry. I’m sure you will find that your new body is quit powerful. Well now, do your best!] God

            With those last words from ‘God’ my vision faded to black and I ended up falling asleep

            shrike_alS 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
            • myskarosM
              myskaros Staff @woodssaayy
              last edited by

              @woodssaayy said in Going to start writing a LN soon! What your thoughts on what I’ve got so far?:

              @myskaros, true. I’ve got the from Earth there basically as a reference for how he has knowledge and basis of common sense that we have here in stead of the other worlds and he will have to learn the new worlds common sense. Also I have it there because the magic in the story is basically elemental magic (EG: Fire, Earth, water, wind & Holy | High Human race royal family members can use all, giving off the OP MC feel). So with the knowledge and understanding from 21st century Earth were he was an honours student he can use that knowledge of the elements to visual create them (High humans can directly control elements and humans cannot).

              But see, you could just as easily explain his common sense by making him a progressive thinker, and make his magic prowess due to his innate intellect and, say, understanding of chemistry. Again, the way you explained your plan, the isekai is just a gimmick to avoid having to properly characterize your protagonist and uses the audience as a crutch. Him coming from another world has nothing to do with the story, it's just an excuse you can use to shuffle details off to the side and exclaim "he's from another world, don't worry about it."

              Whoever said nothing's impossible never tried slamming a revolving door.

              ImIlyazI 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 2
              • ImIlyazI
                ImIlyaz
                last edited by

                filthy harems taking over the world 😒

                Jokes aside (i was actually not joking okay?)
                Will illustrations be present?(if you've mentioned it/someone else has already asked forgive me)

                "I drowned a fish, killed a dead tree and made medicine sick"

                1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                • ImIlyazI
                  ImIlyaz @myskaros
                  last edited by ImIlyaz

                  @myskaros it would be really funny if the MC just got transported into the future and see him struggle with the world's new tech.

                  Mc:
                  "Damn this new generation and their high tech"

                  Random guy:
                  "Dude even I can handle this. What do you mean with 'new generation' anyways? I'M 80! 80!"

                  Mc:
                  (well I'm +5000 years old you dumb oldha- wait I'm older than him.)

                  But it wasn't supposed to be comedy now was it? ^.^

                  "I drowned a fish, killed a dead tree and made medicine sick"

                  TerrenceT 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 3
                  • TerrenceT
                    Terrence Premium Member @ImIlyaz
                    last edited by

                    @imilyaz said in Going to start writing a LN soon! What your thoughts on what I’ve got so far?:

                    @myskaros it would be really funny if the MC just got transported into the future and see him struggle with the world's new tech. ^.^

                    "You mean you have to use your hands? That's like a :baby: 's toy!"

                    Back to the Future 2 is secret best Isekai. =P

                    1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 2
                    • H
                      Hyferzftw
                      last edited by

                      Lol I like the idea but I agree with Myskaros. Also why a truck? It’s always the god damn truck!

                      woodssaayyW 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 3
                      • woodssaayyW
                        woodssaayy @Hyferzftw
                        last edited by

                        @hyferzftw, it’s gotta be the classic clichè truck man..

                        TerrenceT 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 2
                        • TerrenceT
                          Terrence Premium Member @woodssaayy
                          last edited by

                          @hyferzftw said in Going to start writing a LN soon! What your thoughts on what I’ve got so far?:

                          Lol I like the idea but I agree with Myskaros. Also why a truck? It’s always the god damn truck!

                          And then the magic train drives in front as our romantic leads were about to glance at each other and reunite. That dang train! =P

                          1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                          • shrike_alS
                            shrike_al @woodssaayy
                            last edited by

                            @woodssaayy It feels really typically WN so far, if you get what I mean. Like the sort of stuff you find when you're scouring the novelupdates website. But not in a bad sense. :smiley:

                            Anyway, it all depends on how you work on this, right?

                            woodssaayyW 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                            • woodssaayyW
                              woodssaayy @shrike_al
                              last edited by

                              @shrike_al, true.

                              1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                              • Drone205D
                                Drone205 Premium Member
                                last edited by Drone205

                                If You are writing this story I think going on a popular or well-known writers site thing might be good(I know there are some out there just don't know any) or make your own site or blog thing and post it there. If you do post is on a blog site like Weebly or Wix or something then you probably would need to post a new chapter on a regular basis then. If you do make a blog or something then I likely read it. I really like the WN style books. examples of WN style books are:

                                Konosuba
                                Smartphone Isekai
                                So I'm a Spider
                                Rising of the Shield Hero
                                Death March

                                series where there is a forward-moving story yet never stays too long on any 1 arc or adventure or quest. I am still iffy on the whole Isekai AND Future thing. I think it is probably best to ditch the Isekai cuz the 5000+ yrs in the future is pretty much a new world (Earth 5000 yrs ago is not like Earth now heck even 100 yrs ago we have advanced so much). Whether you do the world is a dark age or the technology is so far advanced or a little bit of both where they have the tech but no one remembers how to use them I would like it.

                                1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                                • 1 / 1
                                • First post
                                  Last post