J-Novel Club
    • Login
    • Search
    • Categories
    • Recent
    • Tags
    • Users
    1. Home
    2. Streaming Discussion
    3. Manga Discussion
    Log in to post
    • Newest to Oldest
    • Oldest to Newest
    • Most Posts
    • Most Votes
    • Most Views
    • Philip Reuben

      Now I'm a Demon Lord! (Manga) Vol 3 Discussion
      ever after • • Philip Reuben

      24
      4
      Votes
      24
      Posts
      2491
      Views

      Lily Garden

      Lefi was extra cute in this chapter!

    • Philip Reuben

      D-Genesis (Manga) Vol 1 Discussion
      dgenesis • • Philip Reuben

      44
      0
      Votes
      44
      Posts
      5278
      Views

      I

      @Zerio
      We really don't know, Iori might not even be an explorer as we don't have any reference for her or the guy. She could just easily be an investigator or auditor for the government. After all no one else has been able to auction off orbs. With the design of the jacket, could be JDSF, JDA, PSB, JTA, or even an entity made up for the series. Could be a special investigator unit specifically for dungeon matters.

      spoiler
    • Philip Reuben

      Black Summoner (Manga) Vol 14 Discussion
      black summoner • • Philip Reuben

      10
      0
      Votes
      10
      Posts
      996
      Views

      TheWickerMan

      The Beast King really is the worst.

    • R

      The Retired Demon of the Maxed-Out Village Vol 1 Discussion
      retired demon • • Roro_

      19
      1
      Votes
      19
      Posts
      1977
      Views

      K

      It's fun to see all of this illustrated, especially watching the Duke visualize Bilegga next to Albrea as she talks.

    • R

      Hell Mode: The Hardcore Gamer Dominates in Another World with Garbage Balancing (Manga) Volume 2 Discussion
      hell mode • • Roro_

      7
      0
      Votes
      7
      Posts
      820
      Views

      Torka

      @b-scot-morgan

      It’s explained in the extra page at the end - he can have them out while sleeping, but he won’t gain XP that way so it’s sort of a waste of time

    • R

      The Invincible Little Lady (Manga) Vol 1 Discussion
      invincible • • Roro_

      30
      1
      Votes
      30
      Posts
      4091
      Views

      P

      @arghc said in The Invincible Little Lady (Manga) Vol 1 Discussion:

      Being impaled through the heart by the word balloon was a new one on me and confusing for a moment before processing what was being depicted. Poetic, though.

      I've been seeing that visual metaphor around lately; I think it might be more common in Korean manhwa...
      At times it could be a word balloon bloodbath.

    • schuburner

      The Frontier Lord Begins with Zero Subjects (Manga) Vol 2 Discussion
      frontier lord • • schuburner

      41
      4
      Votes
      41
      Posts
      3366
      Views

      H

      Best decision of her life.

    • Philip Reuben

      I'll Never Set Foot in That House Again! (Manga) Vol 2 Discussion
      illneversetfoot • • Philip Reuben

      22
      0
      Votes
      22
      Posts
      1774
      Views

      TheGrimLich

      @TheWickerMan I mean, I can actually see Mangaret getting her punishment repealed... but only after she's grown accustomed to a life that's the opposite of privilege. She'll need to unlearn all the habits that Mother-Knows-Best drilled into her, and that'll take time. And if her skill isn't sealed while she's growing used to life at the orphanage, there's at least the potential she uses it in anger.

      Really, it's more a version of Charlotte from Formerly the Fallen Daughter of the Duke at the end of the latest volume than it is her Light Novel counterpart (although I wouldn't be surprised if she has some classism she needs to unlearn as well).

    • Philip Reuben

      Monster and Parent Vol 2 Discussion
      monster parent • • Philip Reuben

      10
      1
      Votes
      10
      Posts
      780
      Views

      P

      @Ingraman said in Monster and Parent Vol 2 Discussion:

      I just don’t know (recall?) enough about godlings to know what counts as normal for them, so I’m not sure if it doesn’t happen or just hasn’t yet happened for others. :)

      I'd love to know what the original Japanese terms were, because there can be a more subtle meaning to it compared to the translation.

      Are the godlings kami? And which term do they use for monster?

    • Philip Reuben

      Thompson Vol 2 Discussion
      thompson • • Philip Reuben

      6
      0
      Votes
      6
      Posts
      572
      Views

      P

      Modern day hunters of the supernatural who deal with both old fairytales and modern urban legends, and try to prevent them both from developing into something more dangerous. A great theme. A not so great execution.

      This is one of those series that I really want to like, but can't. It brings up great plot hooks that I'd really love to see explored, then drops them completely, and goes to a random filler chapter not connected to anything else instead. It goes for that mystery vibe where plenty of things are left unexplained, but overdoes it till you can't tell what's going on half of the time. It frequently places speech bubbles in such a way I have no idea who says what. And worst of all, in my opinion, it does a lot of action, a lot of movement, but it's super hard to follow along - there's some motion happening, but what exactly it is is often unclear, leading to a lot of frustration and backtracking in the action scenes.

      All in all, sorry to say, it makes me anticipate something really interesting, then consistently disappoints.

    • Torachan

      Thompson Vol 3 Discussion
      thompson • • Torachan

      1
      0
      Votes
      1
      Posts
      274
      Views

      No one has replied

    • T

      Bad author but good art
      • Tahu

      1
      0
      Votes
      1
      Posts
      241
      Views

      No one has replied

    • Philip Reuben

      Endo and Kobayashi Live! (Manga) Vol 4 Discussion
      live commentary • • Philip Reuben

      12
      3
      Votes
      12
      Posts
      1173
      Views

      P

      I love this so much! This volume opens with the bombshell that is Bal's confession, and it manages to perfectly switch between cute, funny, romantic and dramatic within a single chapter without any of them feeling out of place. The manga is really such a great fit for the source material.

      And when Fiene starts hearing "the voices", she reacts in perfectly Fiene ways - first complaining about how loud they are, then arguing with them that she definitely didn't say anything about marriage so why are they wishing them eternal happiness. :D

      (Plus the weirdest foreshadowing: What do you mean "I don't want you to die again?")

      The whole volume is such a rollercoaster of emotions, from the lows of Lieselotte's nightmares to the heights of love and caring, and back again, usually in the span of few pages. And as usual with Endo and Kobayashi, I open the volume wondering if it will still be engaging given I've been through the story, in various media, four times already, and end the book ecstatic about it all again!

      @Kotenmaru said in Endo and Kobayashi Live! (Manga) Vol 4 Discussion:

      I understand why her father told her what he did, but it always comes off as rather cruel, especially to tell a five year old.

      Full agreement here. The revelation that Lieselotte bottling her emotions inside is because of something her own father said to her always feels like such a tragic moment; it's just words, but in a lot of other versions of the story, it's something that ultimately kills her.

    • schuburner

      Karate Master Isekai Volume 3
      karate isekai • • schuburner

      27
      1
      Votes
      27
      Posts
      2759
      Views

      saffire

      @King-of-the-End https://forums.j-novel.club/topic/7451/manga-display-issues

    • R

      The Coppersmith's Bride Vol 3 Discussion
      coppersmith • • Roro_

      25
      5
      Votes
      25
      Posts
      2725
      Views

      P

      This is so sweet and adorable!

      They've reached the "living together" stage. And I wonder how representative of people of Japan it is, in general, because I can't believe how chaste everybody is. They're living together, but they're hardly ever physically intimate - they hold hands, and sometimes hug, and that's it. To me it feels like a super conservative look at how young couples should be, not something that flesh and blood people would be like. Could be our cultures are just that different?

      Also I'm still fascinated by how gyaru seems to mean "a perfectly ordinary girl, though you can sometimes see her shoulders".

    • Philip Reuben

      Demon Lord, Retry! R (Manga) Vol 5 Discussion
      retry • • Philip Reuben

      10
      4
      Votes
      10
      Posts
      810
      Views

      K

      I'm getting the same issue as Prometheus0000 but with page 29 I think. The one where Akane delivers her finishing blow.

    • R

      The Conqueror from a Dying Kingdom (Manga) Volume 1 Discussion
      dying kingdom • • Roro_

      14
      0
      Votes
      14
      Posts
      2010
      Views

      S

      @mattashii Thanks. It was corrected to "on the battlefield".

      @GeorgeMTO You're right, well spotted. In vol 1 of the LN, Yuri says that Soim is over 90. In the manga he's under the impression that Soim is 90.
      We can't obviously change the number used in the manga, but we tweaked the line very slightly to emphasize that Yuri is just sharing what he's been told.

    • R

      8th Loop for the Win! With Seven Lives’ Worth of XP and the Third Princess’s Appraisal Skill, My Behemoth and I Are Unstoppable! (Manga) Vol 1 Discussion
      8th loop • • Roro_

      6
      0
      Votes
      6
      Posts
      790
      Views

      Z

      In ch 2, the princess said she had the power to know what roads people ought to take. Then MC started thinking how he did his teenage years multiple times.

      At first, I thought the princess's power is to see the path that someone need to take to have a good future.

      But, is "ought" here supposed to be past tense, and her power is to know the path someone has taken?

    • R

      The Unwanted Undead Adventurer (MANGA) Vol 10 Discussion
      unwanted undead • • Roro_

      14
      3
      Votes
      14
      Posts
      1386
      Views

      Geezer Weasalopes

      @Ingraman said in The Unwanted Undead Adventurer (MANGA) Vol 10 Discussion:

      Rentt’s horror story is finally over…

      The backstory has been presented.
      We now return you to your regularly scheduled programming.

      From the perspective of explaining his motivation behind becoming an adventurer, and his being methodical from the beginning...I'm not sure how much could have been cut and still have it be impactful.
      Doesn't change that it's not going to be a favorite reread.

    • R

      I Want to Escape from Princess Lessons! (Manga) Vol 1 Discussion
      princesslessons j-novel heart • • Roro_

      11
      0
      Votes
      11
      Posts
      1541
      Views

      Z

      Oh man, ch 1 was really interesting with how it subverts the broken engagement trope. Then I thought we finally get a shoujo manga where the man respects MC.

      But this just turns into the typical forceful romance but even worse.

    • 1
    • 2
    • 24
    • 25
    • 26
    • 27
    • 28
    • 42
    • 43
    • 26 / 43