@kuali said in Tearmoon Empire (Manga) Vol 8 Discussion:
For the record, I don't actually agree with Mia's point that Sion would have no right to judge Abel (or her) if he didn't try to help beforehand. Judgment, I think, is something that should be done by the most impartial authority available - someone who was personally involved in the situation (regardless of how) is unlikely to fit that particular bill. (And just in general, it is not the job of a child to raise the children around them. There are plenty of people around Mia who should have been raising her better, Sion just isn't one of them.)
Someone like the Duke of Belluga or the King of Remno - someone who hadn't been involved in the revolution on either side - should have been called on to preside over Mia's trial, ideally. And by the same token, were Abel to face trial for his actions in this timeline, it should be the ruler of somewhere like Belluga or Tearmoon that acted as judge, not Sion, or Mia, or any of the other people who get personally involved in this revolution.
At the same time, though, it's also easy to empathize with Mia's perspective. While she may have made mistakes in the original timeline, none of what she did wrong in regards to the famine was done out of malice. In fact, she really had very little to do with what she got executed over other than being a member of the imperial family.