General thing all around that I've been noticing: Ciel and Vincent always refer to Mitia as master, but shouldn't that be mistress since she's, y'know, female?
42%
all while giving orders to his rioters-turned-agents subordinates.
I'm not sure whether this is proper grammar or not, but it sounds kind of awkward nonetheless. Perhaps something along the lines of all while giving orders to his subordinates, the rioters-turned-agents would be better?
67%
I stood in the kitchen, opened the Crimson Book, brought out all the necessary ingredients, and began making pudding. I started by putting sugar and a small amount of water in a pot. Using Medium-Heat Magic, I boiled the contents down until they turned a nice looking red; then I used Hot Water Magic to add hot water and make the caramel sauce.
Er, why is sugar+water turning red from being heated? This seems like either something is missing that should be included or it might have been mistranslated. After rereading it a few times, I would hazard a guess that red might be a mistranslation. Since she's making caramel sauce, I would speculate that it should probably be brown.