J-Novel Club
    • Login
    • Search
    • Categories
    • Recent
    • Tags
    • Users
    1. Home
    2. Streaming Discussion
    3. Manga Discussion
    Log in to post
    • Newest to Oldest
    • Oldest to Newest
    • Most Posts
    • Most Votes
    • Most Views
    • schuburner

      Flung into a New World (Manga) Vol 3 Discussion
      flungnewworld • • schuburner

      15
      0
      Votes
      15
      Posts
      1267
      Views

      Makine

      I'll say it again, it's downright astonishing how much better the pacing is in the manga versus the original novel. Just having the animal reactions there in line with the story is so much better.

    • schuburner

      Crown of Rutile Quartz (Manga) Vol 1 Discussion
      rutile quartz • • schuburner

      14
      0
      Votes
      14
      Posts
      1366
      Views

      Paul Nebeling

      Well, I tip my hat to the manga artist for this week's part. Not only did he capture the looks on Monica and Slaine's faces perfectly after their (ahem) fall, he managed to get the bit with Slaine versus Axe without saying much at all, yet speaking volumes.

      If this keeps up, I'm going to spend the credits to buy both the LN and manga.

    • Philip Reuben

      Demon Lord Retry! R (Manga) Vol 8 Discussion
      retry • • Philip Reuben

      2
      0
      Votes
      2
      Posts
      362
      Views

      I

      v8c5, pg 29:

      panel 2 - Once upon a time, the holy church was more than the holy maidens were more than mere figureheads. -> Missing words? Phrases? It looks as though two sentences/phrases might have collided here, blowing a few words into the weeds. “the holy church was more than the holy maidens, [missing words] were more than mere figureheads”? Or “the holy church was more than [missing words] [and] the holy maidens were more than figureheads.” One of those, perhaps (I vote for option #2!), or maybe my reading comprehension isn’t so good today. ;)
    • Philip Reuben

      Only I Know That This World Is a Game: Volume 9
      game world • • Philip Reuben

      9
      0
      Votes
      9
      Posts
      769
      Views

      Serah

      Poor bunny girl lost her marbles.

    • schuburner

      Eternal Fool's Words of Wisdom (Manga) Vol 6 Discussion
      eternal fool • • schuburner

      17
      3
      Votes
      17
      Posts
      1055
      Views

      D

      And so we continue with a plot line that I'm still not entirely sold on. Asley's motivation for reworking or removing the pleasure district is one-note and his plan isn't very well though out. He doesn't have any personal stakes or established history against pleasure districts so its inclusion in the story at this point feels like a padding side plot that got out of hand.

      His intention to save people when they are placed in front of him is noble, but the situation in the district of that town isn't treated as abnormal by any of the residents. Unpleasant, sure, but not shocking. He's not trying to stop an evil system that's gone out of control under everyone's nose, the evil system is a known element of the town that is working as intended. Aileen brings up that the economic and political forces that made the district in the first place would just reconstitute it once Asley's work was done, and I don't see Asley's plan sticking long term unless he's planning on using that money for systemic change.

    • schuburner

      Wild Last Boss (Manga) Vol 7 Discussion
      wild last boss • • schuburner

      15
      2
      Votes
      15
      Posts
      1242
      Views

      karasutengu

      @Lily-Garden OOPs, is my face red. Sorry 'bout that. I will repost. Thanks.

    • schuburner

      Zero Believers (Manga) Vol 9 Discussion
      zero believers • • schuburner

      12
      2
      Votes
      12
      Posts
      1031
      Views

      N

      @TheGrimLich Would have been perfect if there was a Noah thought bubble "So dense!"

    • A

      Cave King (Manga) Vol 7 Discussion
      cave king • • Adam Jankowski

      10
      1
      Votes
      10
      Posts
      884
      Views

      TheGrimLich

      @Geezer-Weasalopes said in Cave King (Manga) Vol 7 Discussion:

      "This does not bode well" is the phrase springing to mind.

      "This does not bode well" is an understatement. This is an omen of catastrophe... and one can only hope that our dear Heale, with his subjects, can somehow turn the tides. We've seen that relying on just humans wasn't enough. Mayhaps monsters will become the key to destroying this icosahedron of hatred.

    • A

      The Invincible Little Lady (Manga) Vol 10 Discussion
      invincible • • Adam Jankowski

      17
      2
      Votes
      17
      Posts
      1312
      Views

      H

      Always feel kind of weird how detailed the artist draws bodies.

      I wonder if the pedestal was red?

    • Torachan

      From Villainess to Healer (Manga): Volume 3 Discussion
      • Torachan

      12
      2
      Votes
      12
      Posts
      837
      Views

      yumenokage

      @Serah If I really like a light novel series I'll often read the manga too; it doesn't take that much extra time and it's fun to see the art. But for some novel series I generally like but am less keen on, I've dropped the LN but continued with the manga since it's a lower time commitment. My free time is pretty limited, so I can't read as many series I otherwise might in a vacuum. I'll also follow manga-original series.

      For this series, I started with the manga when it started serialization, drawn in by the art. When some time later the LN started serialization, my sense based on what I had read of the manga was that it would probably be one of those series I wouldn't follow both the LN and manga for, so I didn't try it then. But recently, with it going on sale, I did pick up the first volume of the light novel. While I don't hate it, the manga seems like a pretty close adaptation and I think my earlier sense that I wouldn't follow both was right. Usually I think more about missing stuff in an adaptation, but here I think the adaptation might actually be better. I just wish it released a little faster...

    • R

      My Tiny Senpai Vol 1 Discussion
      my tiny senpai • • Roro_

      27
      2
      Votes
      27
      Posts
      3191
      Views

      I

      I’m now a bit confused. My notes say that the first book was prepubbed as five parts, but the series page says the first book is four chapters. Did I mess up my notes? ^^; Hmm… Going back to the prepub book in the iOS app, the parts are listed as parts, and not the chapters shown on the JNC series webpage. But book two is chapters in the app… Heh… @_@

      Edit: /me goes to look at the part 4. Only 17 pages? It was a normal-length book wasn’t it? Why so few pages? Part 3… 57 pages?! 10 chapters? Part 2… 33 pages, five chapters. Seems a bit more normal. Part 1… 23 pages, four chapters. Maybe parts three and four were combined into chapter 3?

    • Philip Reuben

      A Late-Start Tamer’s Laid-Back Life (Manga) Vol 7 Discussion
      latestart tamer • • Philip Reuben

      8
      1
      Votes
      8
      Posts
      723
      Views

      Geezer Weasalopes

      His tamed monsters have maxed out the skill "Intimidate Tamer."

    • schuburner

      Old Knight, New Post (Manga) Vol 1 Discussion
      old knight • • schuburner

      20
      1
      Votes
      20
      Posts
      1558
      Views

      TheGrimLich

      Hi Watt! Welcome to the fight! We've got some real bad apples here, including a guy who probably oughta be removed from the Knights.

    • schuburner

      Frontier Lord (Manga) Vol 10 Discussion
      frontier lord • • schuburner

      16
      2
      Votes
      16
      Posts
      1163
      Views

      Geezer Weasalopes

      The mangaka really is crazy good.
      I know, I keep saying that!
      And then they go beyond what they'd done before.

    • schuburner

      The Magic in this Other World is Too Far Behind! (Manga) Vol 12 Discussion
      isekai mahou • • schuburner

      1
      3
      Votes
      1
      Posts
      269
      Views

      No one has replied

    • A

      The Invincible Summoner Who Crawled Up from Level 1 (Manga) Vol 4 Discussion
      invince summon • • Adam Jankowski

      5
      1
      Votes
      5
      Posts
      368
      Views

      E

      No, that ass isn't broken, it was always like that. Pay it no mind.

      .
      .
      .

      ...I may or may not have been ruined by 'broken ass' jokes in anime...

    • A

      I’m Capped at Level 1?! Thus Begins My Journey to Become the World’s Strongest Badass! Vol 5
      capped at lvl 1 • • Adam Jankowski

      16
      0
      Votes
      16
      Posts
      1520
      Views

      Geezer Weasalopes

      ...having been two parts behind, I've now caught up.
      To horrible news here in the forums.
      It does explain the, as noted, drop in detail in the illustrations; wrapping things up in a hurry.

    • schuburner

      Banished Former Hero (Manga) Vol 8 Discussion
      banished hero • • schuburner

      3
      1
      Votes
      3
      Posts
      273
      Views

      karasutengu

      @Kotenmaru Yeah, and the strange dark discoloration on his skin and face reminds me of demon affects. (unless those are ink spill mistakes by the mangaka - lol)

    • schuburner

      Gag Character (Manga) Vol 6 Discussion
      gag character • • schuburner

      11
      2
      Votes
      11
      Posts
      981
      Views

      b.scot.morgan

      @xdbx A few weeks ago I stumbled across what I think is the official website where new episodes of this manga are posted online by the author/publisher/whoever is in charge of that kind of thing. I can't read Japanese, and don't remember a lot of the LN anyway, so I couldn't really read it and can't say if it is past the end of the LN or not, but it does appear that the manga is still ongoing in Japanese. The dates of the most recent postings on the site were quite recent.

    • schuburner

      Isekai Tensei (Manga) Vol 11 Discussion
      isekai tensei • • schuburner

      5
      0
      Votes
      5
      Posts
      596
      Views

      schuburner

      @Ingraman Thank you for reporting this error. It was likewise flagged in QA and has now been fixed.

    • 1
    • 2
    • 7
    • 8
    • 9
    • 10
    • 11
    • 42
    • 43
    • 9 / 43