J-Novel Club
    • Login
    • Search
    • Categories
    • Recent
    • Tags
    • Users
    1. Home
    2. Streaming Discussion
    3. Manga Discussion
    Log in to post
    • Newest to Oldest
    • Oldest to Newest
    • Most Posts
    • Most Votes
    • Most Views
    • schuburner

      A Livid Lady's Guide to Getting Even (Manga) Vol 2 Discussion!
      livid lady • • schuburner

      21
      1
      Votes
      21
      Posts
      1875
      Views

      S

      Just checked with the LN. The salt embargo was indeed implicated but never mentioned explicitly.
      Most probable the citizens and soldiers still don't know the full impact of a salt shortage.

      Meaning the kingdom and it's soldiers are the aggressors, even without pillaging and raping. And most don't even realize.

    • R

      I'm a Noble on the Brink of Ruin, So I Might as Well Try Mastering Magic (Manga): Volume 1 Discussion
      brink of ruin • • Roro_

      12
      1
      Votes
      12
      Posts
      1164
      Views

      karasutengu

      I do like how the manga is progressing and following the LN. Just wish it could be further along...

    • Torachan

      This Art Club Has a Problem! Vol 3 Discussion
      art club • • Torachan

      23
      2
      Votes
      23
      Posts
      1694
      Views

      P

      I find that I like the series the best for parts that make the least sense. And in that way, the opening part of the book, the dove head ritual, was supreme.
      (Though chapter 14, which is just Collette meeting a random kid on the street and playing a game together, was a close second.)

      Yeah, so the silly art club people are back. This volume didn't quite match the height of the head model chapter of the previous volume, but it was still funny. I think a big part of what makes it work is guessing which way things will go wrong this time. Some chapters are easier (the pool cleaning), some harder (sensei's costume), but things are never quiet around here.

    • Torachan

      Only I Know That This World Is a Game: Volume 4 Discussion
      game world • • Torachan

      11
      1
      Votes
      11
      Posts
      846
      Views

      TheWickerMan

      Oof, think that might be the longest manga chapter I've seen outside of chapter 1s.

    • Torachan

      The Invincible Little Lady (Manga) Vol 3 Discussion
      invincible • • Torachan

      18
      0
      Votes
      18
      Posts
      1218
      Views

      TheGrimLich

      She said "peacefully and internationally" there, right?

    • Philip Reuben

      Duchess in the Attic (Manga) Vol 1 Discussion
      duchess-attic • • Philip Reuben

      61
      0
      Votes
      61
      Posts
      6729
      Views

      P

      @JannyMau said in Duchess in the Attic (Manga) Vol 1 Discussion:

      Interest in this manga seems to have dropped, or at least the commenting has, which is a shame, imo.

      I think you're in the wrong thread for that? This is the first volume discussion thread, there's another for the next volume!

    • R

      Forget Being the Villainess, I Want to Be an Adventurer! (Manga): Vol 1 Discussion
      forget villain j-novel heart • • Roro_

      17
      3
      Votes
      17
      Posts
      1625
      Views

      J

      This manga is so fun - I love Serephione (which, actually... how was that name decided? SerAphione flows far better...), how proactive she is, and how focused!

      Also, watching her stomp some sense into Alma's Stupid Twin was great, and his sudden puppy crush is honestly adorable xD
      I mean, he's a kid. An asshole kid, but very much a kid. There's room to grow.

    • E

      The Unwanted Undead Adventurer (MANGA) Vol 7 Discussion
      unwanted undead • • exedore

      12
      0
      Votes
      12
      Posts
      942
      Views

      R

      Seems every volume introduces some new characters (and relegates the old ones to the background. ...or deletes them. still haven't seen Rina since v1).

      This volume introduced two girls. One is cool, and one is very annoying. However, the "haggling" scene was funny, so I'll cut her some slack.

    • E

      Unwanted Undead Manga Volume 4 Discussion
      • exedore

      3
      0
      Votes
      3
      Posts
      292
      Views

      R

      the tarasque is not something one fights this early
      good luck, my guy

    • Philip Reuben

      Oversummoned, Overpowered, and Over It! (Manga) Vol 6 Discussion
      oversummoned • • Philip Reuben

      5
      1
      Votes
      5
      Posts
      630
      Views

      S

      Hope both the Light Novel series and the Manga series continue.

    • A

      The Unwanted Undead Adventurer (Manga) Vol 11 Discussion
      unwanted undead • • Adam Jankowski

      13
      1
      Votes
      13
      Posts
      978
      Views

      xdrfiredogx

      I forgot just how absurd the flight with the Captain was, given how long it's been since this happened in the novels. The sight of him jumping around with a pair of tree trunks feels like it should have come from some mecha fight. 😁

    • schuburner

      Banished Former Hero (Manga) Vol 1 Discussion
      banished hero • • schuburner

      9
      0
      Votes
      9
      Posts
      944
      Views

      Z

      @TUSF said in Banished Former Hero (Manga) Vol 1 Discussion:

      Chapter 2 is honestly painful to read and make sense of with pages being constantly repeated and put out of order.

      Yeah, and it's still not fixed yet. Well, it has been released and the streaming going to end soon.
      But I wonder if this is fixed in the final release.

    • Torachan

      8th Loop for the Win (Manga) Vol. 3 Discussion
      8th loop • • Torachan

      6
      0
      Votes
      6
      Posts
      390
      Views

      karasutengu

      So I wonder who this new all powerful mystery guy is?

    • Torachan

      Black Summoner (Manga) Vol 15 Discussion
      black summoner • • Torachan

      7
      0
      Votes
      7
      Posts
      605
      Views

      TheGrimLich

      @TheWickerMan We didn't see this fight, but I think it still at least partly took place.

    • Philip Reuben

      The Magician Who Rose From Failure (Manga) Vol 3 Discussion
      magicianfailure • • Philip Reuben

      27
      0
      Votes
      27
      Posts
      2063
      Views

      Roseheart

      @cadero2 said in The Magician Who Rose From Failure (Manga) Vol 3 Discussion:

      Something I wondered in both the LN and manga; Craib is a good uncle, but I wonder, after that first time, why he doesn't quite confront Joshua more often. (I know their brother relationship is complicated because of their own lousy father.)

      Personally, I feel like he probably doesn't see the need. That first argument was before he was training Arcus in magic, and he probably felt he needed someone to stick up for him (just being a kid and all). But once Craib started training Arcus, he learned about Arcus's goal to get payback on Joshua, and he quickly learned that Arcus is no pushover. With how tough Craib is on Arcus after that, he probably figures Arcus can stick up for himself. Plus, he knows Joshua is stubborn, and going off at him isn't going to change his mind. Lecia notes in LN volume 2 that (minor spoiler, but I guess I'll be safe):

      spoiler
      Which probably has something to do with it. But imo, he knows that Arcus will eventually show Joshua up, and in a big way, and that's probably the only chance anyone has of getting the message through his thick skull. I think he's just content to let Arcus take care of Joshua by himself, because he knows he can and will. He might feel like getting involved now would just undermine his nephew.

    • R

      The Invincible Summoner Who Crawled Up from Level 1 (Manga) Vol 1 discussion
      level 1 crawl • • Roro_

      17
      0
      Votes
      17
      Posts
      1323
      Views

      Nakyoruto

      Why is this Manga not available on BOOKWALKER like all the other Manga Volume releases?

    • Philip Reuben

      Now I'm a Demon Lord! (Manga) Vol 5 Discussion
      ever after • • Philip Reuben

      24
      1
      Votes
      24
      Posts
      1919
      Views

      Geezer Weasalopes

      @Geezer-Weasalopes said in Now I'm a Demon Lord! (Manga) Vol 5 Discussion:

      If he wants the fight of his life...he'll get it.
      If he expects to win it and be left alive...his disappointment will be of short duration.

      Turns out he doesn't mind dying if the fight was good enough.
      He was true to his passion, he wasn't a bully...just not sane in his desire for a fight.
      He clearly got off on a good enough fight, so his head was miswired in a dangerous manner.
      Doesn't make his actions acceptable, but it still makes him just a tad less vile that he wasn't totes sadistic, that he really was a battle junkie of that caliber.
      Still someone needing elimination for the common good.

    • Torachan

      Hell Mode: The Hardcore Gamer Dominates in Another World with Garbage Balancing (Manga) Volume 3 Discussion
      hell mode • • Torachan

      16
      1
      Votes
      16
      Posts
      1134
      Views

      karasutengu

      Way to go Allen! Kick butt and take names!

    • Philip Reuben

      D-Genesis (Manga) Vol 2 Discussion
      dgenesis • • Philip Reuben

      68
      3
      Votes
      68
      Posts
      5626
      Views

      sorvani

      Seeing that this volume releases this week, I'm now anxious for volume 3!

      Actually I want volume 5 because the Bookwalker cover has the Arthurs....

    • schuburner

      Otome Heroine's Fight for Survival (Manga) Vol 1 Discussion
      otome heroine • • schuburner

      21
      1
      Votes
      21
      Posts
      2691
      Views

      Shiroi Hane

      @Zerio said in Otome Heroine's Fight for Survival (Manga) Vol 1 Discussion:

      Ch 1 pg 4: it seems like we're missing the other half of the color page?

      You're not wrong title page spread

      Ch 2: I'm really confused where she got her supplies. She said white bread was rare, so where did she get them?

      The manga skipped it, but as well as taking The Woman's supplies she also took some clothes and food etc from the orphanage (and specifically good food the old woman had kept to herself)

    • 1
    • 2
    • 17
    • 18
    • 19
    • 20
    • 21
    • 39
    • 40
    • 19 / 40