@Jon-Mitchell said in Path of an S-Rank Adventurer Vol 1 Discussion:
I think he's a bit of both, grimdark and tsundere. (or I have a different impression of what the term means)
In fairness to you, grimdark is fundamentally a genre descriptor, not a character descriptor, so I think there's probably a much larger degree of subjective variance here. To put it another way, I think we'd all agree this story isn't grimdark.
As for Hyse's grimdarkness specifically... /shrug. I'm not invested in arguing against it, but looking at that Wikipedia entry, there's a consistent emphasis on cynicism, nihilism, and "doing bad things even when doing good is an option".
It's for that reason that I pointed out the "giving the only remaining flower to Prescea" thing -- that's fundamentally not a grimdark thing to do, and it happened much closer to the start of the story. He also didn't directly take credit for it, and simply reported that he failed the quest because the flowers were corrupted in the fight (IIRC they only realised he gave the only saved one to heal the queen when the queen herself reported it or some such?).
But there's definitely room to disagree (I can't really defend him wearing all black).