@holatuwol said in God Sleeps in Seafoam Vol. 2 Discussion!:
@Travis-Butler said in God Sleeps in Seafoam Vol. 2 Discussion!:
Yeah. My point is that dealing with Akira without knowing about his history has the potential to hit land mines, if they do something that triggers one of his negative experiences with the Ugetsus.
As a reader, if we're supposed to suspect he still has land mines, then I'm led to question what the point of the Cleanse My Past and Erase My Sins chapters was.
We're supposed to believe he would have died if he failed to come to terms with his past, and that his survival is a clear sign that he mostly succeeded in doing so. He casts off his regrets related to his mother and older relatives, comes to terms with his regrets related to his brother, wants to hold on to memories of the people who loved and cherished him, and clings to a desire to be acknowledged.
Should we really have to suspect that he could be triggered by something that only vaguely resembles things he has supposedly already come to terms with and left behind him?
You’re only thinking of “triggered” in terms of trauma. I’m thinking about suspicion, disbelief, mistrust, attempting to hide your actions, etc. You don’t have to have PTSD flashbacks to think “the Eight Houses treat you like sh*t if you’re not a favored son”, for example. Or not want to get involved with them any more than he has to. You think he won’t be wary if Saki’s dad starts trying to make nice with him?
If you don’t like the term ‘land mines’, how about ‘things that will trip you up if you don’t know about his experience of noble family prejudice’? The point is that he’s got a history of growing up in a noble family and living with their mistreatment; his ritual cleansing means he won’t snap and go postal, but his actions in the guard suggest that’s still heavily shaping his life.