@shiratori-keira said in JNC OLN Contest 2025 Finalists! - Discussion:
I'm just a bit curious about how the judging works. Like, are the judges American or Japanese? From JNC or Kadokawa? Do Kadokawa's editors only read the works that pass to the final round?
We got a bit more information on the judges last year. The initial judges were mostly JNC staff, with Sam himself doing a large amount of reading. But the final judges were Sam, Frog-Kun (aka Kim Morrissy, a long time reviewer and translator for Japanese material and also an author themself), Akiko Fujita (Chief Editor at Kadokawa/Enterbrain) and Carlo Zen (Japanese author whose most known work is Saga of Tanya the Evil). Bookwalker also likely had multiple people from their management committee discussing who got their prize.
Unsure how this has changed this year (probably no Carlo Zen, definitely no Frog-kun) as we didn't have someone taking photos of every slide this year. Maybe once Sam has unwound after the con he'll give us the full presentation with reviewer comments.