@nappingcub said in Water Magician Arc 1 Vol. 5 Discussion:
The author having Ryo and Abel leaving prominent enemies alive after defeating them makes my head hurt.
Agreed. It's very PG, but it's objectively ridiculous to participate in a war without the resolve to kill your enemies. All the allies that he loses to them once they re-enter battle are on his shoulders.
I actually think this was a huge mistake for Ryo to enter the war at all. He's not a mercenary. And he can't claim adventurer neutrality when he's clearly fighting for one of the sides. Rescueing his pupils was fine - it's in character and I could see him leaving the soldiers alive, then, on the basis of not choosing sides. And he could have maybe tagged along to the battlefield as Abel's bodyguard or something like that, without ruining his character. But to actively enter the world stage on behalf of one power at the expense of another strikes me as a huge and unwelcome shift in the story.